Edge Rewrite
restyle Source code View original
// HTMLRewriter · presentation

This page was redesigned at the edge.

Cloudflare fetched the original article and streamed it through HTMLRewriter to apply an entirely new visual system without rebuilding the source page.

Jump to content

Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Statistics 2010

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This page presents arbitration data and statistics for 2010. For other years see:

Requests

[edit]
  • Legend: A=Accept, D=Decline, R=Recuse, C=Comment, I=Inactive/away, N=Not eligible.

Case requests

[edit]
  • Requests: 78; average duration: 6.4 days; accepted: 14 (18%); declined: 52 (67%); disposed by motion: 6 (8%); withdrawn: 6 (8%).

Involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Case requests involving 2010 arbs only
RequestOpenedClosedDaysDispADRCICarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
John J. Bulten06:46, 23-Dec-201019:05, 25-Dec-20103Declined04001INNDDDNDNNN
YellowMonkey16:38, 30-Nov-201021:16, 24-Dec-201024Motion26011DAINNDDCDNDDANNN
Cousin Marriage10:23, 4-Dec-201001:30, 14-Dec-201010Declined06002DIINNDDDDNDNNN
Ejaculation Photos22:04, 10-Dec-201001:29, 14-Dec-20103Declined07002DIINNDDDDDNDNNN
Money multiplier22:37, 1-Dec-201018:02, 3-Dec-20102Declined05001DIINNDDDNDNNN
WikipediaExperts20:23, 29-Nov-201018:46, 30-Nov-20101Declined05001IDNNDDDDNNNN
Military history POV-bias19:19, 28-Nov-201013:18, 30-Nov-20102Accepted70201AIANNRAAANRAANNN
Adnan Oktar14:15, 19-Nov-201010:51, 25-Nov-20106Declined05001DINNDDNDDNNN
MickMacNee15:56, 12-Nov-201010:47, 25-Nov-201013Declined45001DIANNDDADNDAANNN
Longevity23:45, 18-Nov-201014:47, 22-Nov-20104Accepted80102RIANNAAAANAAAINN
Eroberer21:38, 7-Nov-201022:12, 15-Nov-20108Declined05012DINNDDDNCDINN
Edward32110:42, 25-Oct-201023:35, 7-Nov-201014Declined17002DIDNNDDDDNDAINN
Pumpie13:51, 11-Oct-201017:17, 20-Oct-20109Declined05022ICNNDCDDDDINN
Cultural Judaism17:12, 5-Oct-201016:07, 11-Oct-20106Declined05003IDNNDDIDDINN
Transcendental Meditation 203:20, 21-Sep-201007:23, 1-Oct-201010Declined05102IDNNDIDDDRNN
Stevertigo 223:47, 26-Sep-201017:15, 29-Sep-20103Accepted80003IAANNAAAAIAAINN
Secret18:44, 22-Sep-201001:49, 23-Sep-20100Withdrawn01003INNIDINN
MOS:JP – Romanization for words of English origin22:04, 7-Sep-201014:49, 21-Sep-201014Declined05013IDNNCDDDIDINN
Disburbed: Asylum (Release Date)06:19, 27-Aug-201003:17, 30-Aug-20103Declined07004DIDINNDDDDIDINN
Cabal: World War II article15:08, 23-Aug-201003:17, 30-Aug-20107Declined07004DIDINNDDDDIDINN
Blablaaa22:06, 31-Jul-201020:19, 19-Aug-201019Declined16303DAIINNRDDRDRIDDNN
State Church of the Roman Empire15:50, 11-Aug-201013:49, 15-Aug-20104Declined07002DIINNDDDDDDNN
Noloop and Slrubenstein18:46, 6-Aug-201013:48, 15-Aug-20109Declined06012CIINNDDDDDDNN
Designation of existence of historical Jesus as fact …19:29, 27-Jul-201019:36, 29-Jul-20102Declined06001DINNDDDDDNN
Ethnic Advocacy and Editor COI12:34, 19-Jul-201015:17, 20-Jul-20101Declined05003DDINNIIDDDNN
Blocking and unblocking17:47, 11-Jul-201002:39, 16-Jul-20104Declined07012DINNDIDDDDDCNN
Appeal of sanction against Aregakn23:12, 9-Jun-201018:37, 24-Jun-201015Declined05023IINNCIDCDDDDNN
Stephan Schulz? & Lar21:14, 20-May-201000:30, 13-Jun-201023Declined11342CRCINNICCADRRNN
Climate change12:43, 25-May-201000:30, 13-Jun-201018Accepted60312CRAINNIAAAAARRNN
Sock Puppet Standards of Evidence09:17, 4-Jun-201000:28, 13-Jun-20109Declined05213IRDINNICDDDDRNN
Race and Intelligence13:13, 1-Jun-201011:29, 7-Jun-20106Accepted60103IAINNIARAAAANN
Attempt to create Wikipedia policy about longevity of citation needed tags …00:46, 31-May-201023:45, 31-May-20101Withdrawn01003IINNIDNN
Keegscee20:18, 23-May-201017:02, 30-May-20107Declined05022DINNDIDDCCDNN
Districts of Kosovo in Serbia21:25, 18-May-201021:05, 21-May-20103Declined06001DINNDDDDDNN
A Nobody17:06, 17-May-201013:16, 20-May-20103Motion02121RCCINNDDNN
1953 Iranian coup POV15:34, 27-Apr-201016:26, 8-May-201011Declined44015AIAINIDDICAADDINN
CONMEBOL tables13:57, 5-May-201016:25, 8-May-20103Declined06005DIINIIDDDDDINN
Controversial edits to Sharia article ...13:14, 23-Apr-201016:36, 30-Apr-20107Declined06002DNDDIDDDNI
Christ myth theory14:43, 13-Apr-201001:47, 18-Apr-20104Declined09001DDNDIDDDDDDNI
Alastair Haines 218:28, 13-Apr-201001:23, 18-Apr-20104Accepted80001AANAIAAAAANI
COI edits in respect of living individuals15:47, 27-Mar-201013:47, 6-Apr-201010Declined13131DANCDCCDRNI
Russavia's request for arbitration enforcement concerning Biophys06:43, 26-Mar-201005:04, 6-Apr-201011Accepted81001DANAAAAAAANI
Dirty, Dangerous and Demeaning20:35, 27-Mar-201021:40, 30-Mar-20103Declined06001NDDDDDDNI
Enforcement of Climate Change discretionary sanctions00:49, 17-Mar-201021:02, 29-Mar-201013Declined05102DNDIDDDRNI
A Nobody05:51, 14-Mar-201023:26, 19-Mar-20106Accepted130102RAAANAAAAAIAAAAANI
WP:OWN in Judaism articles06:55, 13-Mar-201010:19, 16-Mar-20103Declined07001DNDDDDDDNI
Durova and Shoemaker's Holiday22:04, 9-Mar-201004:51, 15-Mar-20105Motion23431RDCNCDCRRAARDNI
Trusilver's unblock of Brews ohare06:22, 1-Mar-201004:17, 15-Mar-201014Motion00071CCCNCCCCNI
Elizabeth II08:54, 9-Mar-201000:41, 12-Mar-20103Declined08022ICNDDDCDDDDDNI
Malik Shabazz11:09, 6-Mar-201017:38, 11-Mar-20105Declined07042ICNDDDCDCDDCDNI
Gibraltar12:16, 5-Mar-201016:39, 11-Mar-20106Accepted90202IAANRAAAARAAANI
User:Steaphen13:05, 1-Mar-201021:28, 8-Mar-20107Declined08003INDDDDDDDDNI
Catholic Church18:09, 22-Feb-201018:36, 4-Mar-201010Declined25203IDINADDDRRDANI
Nigam Arora21:45, 28-Feb-201018:35, 4-Mar-20104Declined06014IINIDDDDCDDNI
Christ myth theory23:56, 23-Feb-201006:12, 2-Mar-20106Declined06013IINDDDDDDCNI
Bourbon-Two Sicilies01:09, 19-Feb-201016:11, 24-Feb-20106Declined08003IINDDDDDDDDNI
Pedro II of Brazil03:01, 20-Feb-201016:08, 24-Feb-20105Withdrawn07004IINIDDDDDDDNI
Ikip14:25, 17-Feb-201016:30, 22-Feb-20105Withdrawn06223IRINCDDRDDDCDNI
ChildofMidnight20:11, 15-Feb-201004:23, 21-Feb-20105Accepted60134IRAINIACCACAAANI
Proofreader77 blocks02:41, 15-Feb-201020:13, 20-Feb-20106Declined18005IDINIDDIADDDDDNI
Asgardian21:36, 13-Feb-201003:54, 19-Feb-20105Accepted40045IINIAAICACACCNI
Transcendental Meditation movement19:15, 15-Feb-201010:57, 18-Feb-20103Accepted90015IAIAIAAIAACAAANI
Zeno's paradoxes07:13, 11-Feb-201001:12, 14-Feb-20103Declined08005IIIDIDDDDDDDNI
Fringe Theory Ground Rules14:03, 6-Feb-201017:30, 10-Feb-20104Declined08005IIIDIDDDDDDDNI
Defender 91100:51, 5-Feb-201016:10, 5-Feb-20101Withdrawn03003IDIDDNI
Jéské Couriano22:34, 30-Jan-201004:45, 3-Feb-20103Declined06003IIDDDDDDNI
David Irving Biography16:05, 31-Jan-201004:42, 3-Feb-20103Declined07003IIDDDDDDDNI
WP:PROD wheel war09:16, 23-Jan-201012:01, 31-Jan-20108Declined48031ADCIDDDDCDADDAANC
Craigy14418:51, 20-Jan-201000:42, 30-Jan-20109Motion03082CDDICCCCCCDCNI
BLP deletions01:52, 21-Jan-201018:48, 22-Jan-20102Motion91220ARAAAARCCADAANA
Misty Willows17:45, 21-Jan-201003:48, 22-Jan-20100Withdrawn00012ICNI
MZMcBride 218:53, 16-Jan-201022:53, 19-Jan-20103Accepted92141CRAAAAAADDCACAACI
POV tag at Israel and the apartheid analogy21:50, 14-Jan-201005:06, 18-Jan-20103Declined08102DIDDRDDDDDI
Badagnani02:30, 12-Jan-201017:27, 17-Jan-20106Declined09012CIDDDDDDDDDI
Chabad movement editors07:17, 5-Jan-201007:01, 9-Jan-20104Accepted81003AIAAAIAAADAI
Character list merge02:27, 5-Jan-201005:18, 7-Jan-20102Declined010002DIDDDDDDDDDI
Climate Change02:08, 30-Dec-200922:59, 5-Jan-20107Declined110121CADDDDCDDDDDRDI
Climate Change Probation09:46, 2-Jan-201022:56, 5-Jan-20104Declined09102DIDDDDDDDDRI

Requests: 78; average duration: 6.4 days; accepted: 14 (18%); declined: 52 (67%); disposed by motion: 6 (8%); withdrawn: 6 (8%)

Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Case requests involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
RequestOpenedClosedDaysDispADRCICarChlCorFayFloFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirSteStsVasWiz

Requests: 0

Clarifications and other requests

[edit]
  • Requests: 89; average duration: 20.3 days; declined: 30 (34%); disposed by clarification: 27 (30%); disposed by motion: 27 (30%); withdrawn: 3 (3%); removed: 2 (2%).

Involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Clarifications and other requests involving 2010 arbs only
RequestOpenedClosedDaysDispRCICarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Amend : Date delinking20:22, 11-Nov-201017:41, 20-Dec-201039Declined062ICINNCCCNCCNNN
Clarify : Race and intelligence03:55, 29-Nov-201021:37, 17-Dec-201019Motion142IINNCRNCCCNNN
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list23:19, 6-Dec-201002:54, 10-Dec-20103Clarification042ICINNCCNCNNN
Clarify : Palestine-Israel articles08:24, 19-Nov-201001:51, 9-Dec-201020Clarification142IINNCRNCCCNNN
Amend : Russavia-Biophys15:32, 7-Nov-201001:50, 9-Dec-201031Declined062CIINNCCCNCCNNN
Amend : Russavia-Biophys14:40, 25-Nov-201017:08, 26-Nov-20101Removed021INNCCNNNN
Amend : Climate change17:23, 12-Nov-201019:13, 23-Nov-201011Declined052CINNCCCNCINN
Clarify : Climate change04:50, 11-Nov-201019:11, 23-Nov-201013Clarification252CICNNCRCNCRINN
Amend : Kehrli23:12, 5-Nov-201006:56, 21-Nov-201015Declined082CICNNCCCNCCCINN
Amend : Speed of light16:38, 15-Nov-201014:51, 18-Nov-20103Motion042CINNCNCCINN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list22:57, 21-Sep-201017:07, 13-Nov-201053Motion242CICNNCNRRCINN
Clarify : Badlydrawnjeff21:31, 27-Oct-201004:59, 13-Nov-201016Clarification062CINNCCCNCCINN
Clarify : Race and intelligence21:03, 25-Oct-201004:58, 13-Nov-201018Clarification052CICNNCNCCINN
Clarify : Climate change20:05, 25-Oct-201021:11, 9-Nov-201015Motion002INNNINN
Clarify : Climate change00:15, 24-Oct-201021:05, 9-Nov-201017Clarification062CICNNCCNCCINN
Clarify : Pseudoscience21:54, 22-Oct-201020:17, 9-Nov-201018Clarification012INNNCINN
Amend : Date delinking06:57, 29-Oct-201014:39, 9-Nov-201011Declined022INNCCINN
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance04:01, 2-Oct-201014:47, 8-Nov-201037Motion032CICNNNCINN
Clarify DIGWUREN21:52, 15-Oct-201017:32, 7-Nov-201023Clarification042CINNCCCNINN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list09:45, 6-Oct-201019:11, 31-Oct-201025Declined122ICNNNRCINN
Clarify : Speed of light15:14, 26-Sep-201002:54, 21-Oct-201024Clarification032INNCCCINN
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list00:29, 7-Oct-201002:54, 21-Oct-201014Clarification022ICNNCINN
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list20:41, 16-Oct-201002:38, 21-Oct-20104Withdrawn012INNCINN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list09:07, 11-Sep-201017:13, 20-Oct-201039Declined142INNCCCRCINN
Amend : Koavf04:32, 15-Oct-201017:12, 20-Oct-20106Declined042INNCCCCINN
Amend : ChildofMidnight02:11, 16-Oct-201017:12, 20-Oct-20105Declined032INNCCCINN
Clarify : Transcendental Meditation movement20:24, 12-Sep-201008:17, 12-Oct-201029Clarification053ICNNCICCCINN
Amend : Race and intelligence06:27, 10-Sep-201016:20, 11-Oct-201031Declined053ICNNCICCCINN
Amend : ChildofMidnight09:36, 27-Aug-201009:11, 23-Sep-201027Declined072CICNNCCCCCINN
Amend : Speed of light05:40, 29-Aug-201008:58, 23-Sep-201025Declined033CINNCICINN
Clarify : Race and intelligence09:08, 23-Aug-201018:03, 5-Sep-201013Clarification071CCNNCCCCCINN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list20:58, 7-Jul-201017:45, 4-Sep-201059Motion252CICNNCCRRCINN
Amend : Tothwolf06:56, 5-Aug-201014:45, 4-Sep-201030Motion052CCNNCICCINN
Amend : Date delinking22:11, 11-Jul-201013:45, 4-Sep-201055Motion281RICNNCCCCCCCRNN
Amend : Fringe science13:38, 13-Aug-201000:53, 28-Aug-201014Declined352CRCINNCRRCCINN
Amend : Speed of light17:01, 11-Aug-201016:10, 22-Aug-201011Motion032CIINNCCNN
Amend : Everyking 310:01, 17-Aug-201019:25, 19-Aug-20102Declined064CIIINNCCCCCINN
Clarify : Speed of light07:00, 4-Aug-201003:12, 12-Aug-20108Clarification032CINNCICNN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list19:58, 21-Jul-201003:16, 4-Aug-201013Declined322INNRCCRRINN
Clarify User:Betacommand17:06, 20-Jul-201003:09, 4-Aug-201014Clarification042INNCCCCINN
Amend : Betacommand 215:48, 25-Jul-201007:12, 31-Jul-20106Motion012INNCINN
Clarify : Ireland article names08:42, 29-Jun-201019:22, 29-Jul-201030Clarification021CINNCNN
Clarify User:SlimVirgin00:47, 18-Jul-201019:21, 29-Jul-201012Clarification031INNCCCNN
Clarify : The Troubles15:27, 20-Jul-201019:13, 29-Jul-20109Clarification051CINNCCCCNN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list03:04, 27-Jun-201001:43, 29-Jul-201032Declined362CINNRICCCRRCCNN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list10:29, 28-Jun-201023:55, 20-Jul-201023Motion233INNICCIRRCNN
Amend : Ferrylodge06:22, 22-May-201020:12, 7-Jul-201047Withdrawn162CRCINNICCCCNN
Amend : Speed of light18:17, 16-Jun-201020:08, 7-Jul-201021Motion032CINNICCNN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list19:53, 21-Jun-201019:51, 2-Jul-201011Motion002INNINN
Amend : Tothwolf05:46, 16-May-201019:33, 2-Jul-201048Motion052CCINNICCCNN
Amend : Pseudoscience13:09, 15-Jun-201019:11, 2-Jul-201017Motion032INNCICCNN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list18:04, 1-Jun-201020:55, 21-Jun-201020Motion123ICINNICRNN
Clarify Juice Plus16:22, 17-Jun-201010:42, 20-Jun-20103Removed023IINNICCNN
Amend : Derek Smart01:56, 22-Apr-201018:29, 9-Jun-201049Declined152IINNRCCCCCNN
Clarify : Date delinking07:11, 30-Apr-201018:25, 9-Jun-201040Clarification222RCINNICRNN
Clarify : Armenia-Azerbaijan 216:45, 18-Apr-201013:30, 20-May-201032Clarification062CICINNCCCCNN
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance12:58, 24-Apr-201013:23, 20-May-201026Declined051CCCINNCCNN
Amend : Eastern European mailing list21:34, 15-Apr-201000:43, 6-May-201020Motion166CICINICICCRCINI
Clarify : Tang Dynasty20:31, 18-Feb-201015:23, 4-May-201075Motion074CICINCICCCCNI
Clarify User:Sulmues20:35, 15-Apr-201010:33, 2-May-201017Clarification056CIINIICCCCINI
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance20:27, 13-Apr-201016:32, 22-Apr-20109Declined142CNICCRCNI
Clarify ban of User:Offliner10:43, 11-Apr-201002:09, 14-Apr-20103Clarification051CCNCCCNI
Clarify : Motion regarding biographies of living people deletions08:27, 7-Mar-201019:20, 7-Apr-201031Clarification161CCNCRCCCNI
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley16:04, 16-Mar-201019:18, 7-Apr-201022Clarification131CNCCRNI
Amend : Scientology22:01, 12-Mar-201021:30, 30-Mar-201018Declined052CCCNICCNI
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance07:33, 16-Feb-201020:39, 30-Mar-201043Motion242CCNRCIRCNI
Amend : Asmahan13:09, 20-Feb-201012:14, 26-Mar-201034Declined032CNICCNI
Amend : Falun Gong04:34, 23-Feb-201003:31, 13-Mar-201018Declined041CNCCCNI
Clarify : Ireland article names17:42, 21-Feb-201001:12, 12-Mar-201018Clarification142INCCCCRNI
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley21:08, 27-Feb-201005:15, 10-Mar-201010Withdrawn152ICNCCCCRNI
Clarify : Ireland article names19:07, 17-Feb-201016:03, 5-Mar-201016Motion234ICINICCRRNI
Amend : Footnoted quotes07:42, 14-Feb-201014:35, 2-Mar-201016Declined154ICINICCRCCNI
Amend : Speed of light05:02, 8-Feb-201014:32, 2-Mar-201022Declined074ICINICCCCCCNI
Clarify : C68-FM-SV00:00, 12-Feb-201019:02, 14-Feb-20103Clarification046IIIIICCCCNI
Amend : Eastern European mailing list03:32, 28-Jan-201018:21, 13-Feb-201017Motion014CIIINI
Amend : Ryulong08:46, 21-Jan-201017:56, 3-Feb-201013Declined292CCICRCCRCCCCNI
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley09:11, 11-Jan-201023:49, 2-Feb-201023Motion522RIRRCCRRNI
Amend : Eastern European mailing list08:42, 22-Jan-201011:12, 28-Jan-20106Motion132CICRCNI
Amend : Eastern European mailing list06:23, 23-Jan-201011:11, 28-Jan-20105Motion012ICNI
Amend : Speed of light20:12, 13-Jan-201002:06, 27-Jan-201013Motion052CICCCCI
Amend : Falun Gong22:02, 14-Jan-201007:18, 19-Jan-20104Motion112ICRI
Amend : Asmahan18:08, 3-Jan-201007:11, 19-Jan-201016Declined042CICCCI
Amend : September 11 conspiracy theories09:46, 4-Jan-201007:08, 19-Jan-201015Declined182CICCRCCCCCI
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list21:55, 31-Dec-200907:05, 19-Jan-201018Clarification0102CICCCCCCCCCI
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list01:28, 1-Jan-201007:03, 19-Jan-201018Clarification1111CCCCCCCCRCCCI
Amend : Asmahan19:26, 23-Dec-200918:08, 10-Jan-201018Declined063CICICCCCI
Amend : Obama articles01:11, 1-Jan-201017:57, 10-Jan-201010Declined053CICICCCI
Amend : West Bank - Judea and Samaria20:43, 29-Dec-200917:54, 10-Jan-201012Declined072CCICCCCCI
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley00:56, 1-Jan-201016:04, 10-Jan-201010Motion033ICCICI

Requests: 89; average duration: 20.3 days; declined: 30 (34%); disposed by clarification: 27 (30%); disposed by motion: 27 (30%); withdrawn: 3 (3%); removed: 2 (2%)

Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Clarifications and other requests involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
RequestOpenedClosedDaysDispRCICarChlCorFayFloFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirSteStsVasWiz

Requests: 0

Arb activity

[edit]

Legend

[edit]

The following two tables each contain three sections, the first covering case requests, the second other requests and the third all requests. The column headings have the following meanings:

  • ER (eligible requests): Indicates the beginning of a new section and gives the total number respectively, of case requests, other requests, or all requests, for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of requests for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as inactive/away at the time of the request's closing, and did not act on the request (i.e. did not recuse. accept, decline or comment) (count of "I"s); as a percentage of ER.
  • R (recused): The total number of requests for which this arb recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (ER − I).
  • V (voted): The total number of case requests this arb voted to accept or decline (count of "A"s or "D"s); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of requests for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as active at the time of the request's closing, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
  • A (accept): The total number of case requests this arb voted to accept (count of "A"s); as a percentage of V.
  • D (decline): The total number of case requests this arb voted to decline (count of "D"s); as a percentage of V.
  • C (comment): The total number of other requests this arb commented on (count of "C"s); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).

Arb activity (2010)

[edit]
Arb activity (2010) — requests
ArbERI%R%V%DNA%A%D%ERI%R%C%DNA%ERI%R%DNA%
Carcharoth782228%47%3363%1121%618%2782%89910%23%4659%3241%1673119%64%4333%
Cool Hand Luke782329%713%715%4083%229%571%893742%36%1122%3878%1676036%109%7880%
Coren781215%00%2944%3248%1862%1138%891618%00%3244%4156%1672817%00%7353%
FayssalF783849%00%410%3280%375%125%893640%12%00%52100%1677444%11%8491%
Fritzpoll1700%00%1271%424%433%867%1600%16%427%1173%3300%13%1547%
Hersfold431023%00%1545%1648%533%1067%32722%14%625%1875%751723%12%3460%
Kirill Lokshin7800%34%3344%4053%721%2679%8900%44%3238%5362%16700%74%9358%
KnightLago78810%00%4767%2130%1226%3574%891011%00%79%7291%1671811%00%9362%
Mailer diablo78912%11%2841%4059%414%2486%8967%11%67%7693%167159%21%11677%
Newyorkbrad7811%11%4357%1621%1126%3274%8944%34%4352%3948%16753%42%5535%
Risker7823%57%3752%2941%822%2978%8933%33%2733%5667%16753%85%8555%
Rlevse6669%12%3864%1729%1232%2668%7057%23%2641%3759%136118%32%5444%
Roger Davies7800%34%3243%3952%722%2578%8900%67%2125%6275%16700%95%10164%
Shell Kinney7834%11%4358%2432%1433%2967%8911%1315%4155%3445%16742%149%5839%
SirFozzie7800%34%6283%912%1727%4573%8933%22%4655%3845%16732%53%4730%
Steve Smith691217%814%3776%816%1027%2773%833036%713%2452%2248%1524228%1514%3032%
Vassyana700%00%571%114%120%480%1000%110%9100%00%1700%16%16%
Wizardman413995%00%150%00%1100%00%3232100%000737197%00%00%
Case requestsClarifications and other requestsAll requests

Arb activity (departing 2009)

[edit]
Arb activity (departing 2009) — requests
ArbERI%R%V%DNA%A%D%ERI%R%C%DNA%ERI%R%DNA%
FloNight0000000000000000
Stephen Bain0000000000000000
Case requestsClarifications and other requestsAll requests

Motions

[edit]
  • Legend: S=Support, O=Oppose, A=Abstain, Ac=Active arbs, R=Recuse, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible, Offered = the arb who posted the motion.
  • Publicly offered motions: 60; average duration: 7.4 days; passed: 48 (80%); failed: 12 (20%).
Motions involving 2010 arbs only
MotionPer RequestOpenedClosedDaysDispSOAAcRIMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizOffered
Motion 1YellowMonkey01:09, 20-Dec-201021:16, 24-Dec-20105Failed35011016OOSINNOOSNOSNNNSir
Motion 2YellowMonkey04:13, 20-Dec-201021:16, 24-Dec-20105Passed82011016SSOINNSSSSSNSONNNCar
Remedy 6 terminatedClarify : Race and intelligence10:08, 15-Dec-201021:37, 17-Dec-20102Passed6009125SISINNSRNSSSNNNRog
Brews ohare banned for one yearAmend : Speed of light21:25, 15-Nov-201014:51, 18-Nov-20103Passed81011026OISNNSSSSSNSSINNKir
Piotrus topic ban narrowedAmend : Eastern European mailing list (2)13:49, 5-Nov-201017:07, 13-Nov-20108Passed5008325SISNNRSSNRRSINNCor
Climate change "Scope of topic bans" amemdedClarify : Climate change (2)16:10, 2-Nov-201021:11, 9-Nov-20107Passed90011026SISSNNSSSSNSSINNRog
Climate change "Appeal of topic bans" amemdedClarify : Climate change (2)16:10, 2-Nov-201021:11, 9-Nov-20107Passed80111026SISANNSSSSNSSINNRog
Marknutley and William M.Connolley unblockedClarify : Climate change (2)16:10, 2-Nov-201021:11, 9-Nov-20107Failed34211025OIOSNNOOSANSAINNRog
Ohconfucius permitted to use automationAmend : Date delinking21:00, 30-Oct-201014:39, 9-Nov-201010Passed70011126RISNNSSSSSSINNKir
Per Honor et Gloria topic ban extended indefinitelyAmend : Franco-Mongol alliance04:01, 2-Oct-201014:47, 8-Nov-201037Passed60010126SISNNSSNSRSINNSir
Martintg topic ban liftedAmend : Eastern European Mailing List (4)23:57, 27-Aug-201017:45, 4-Sep-20108Failed16010226SIONNOOOOORRINNCar
Martintg topic ban modifiedAmend : Eastern European Mailing List (4)01:25, 28-Aug-201017:45, 4-Sep-20108Passed90010136SISNNSSSSSSRISINNNew
Tothwolf, Miami33139, JBSupreme are banned from interactingAmend : Tothwolf10:44, 24-Aug-201014:45, 4-Sep-201011Passed100012027SISNNSSSSSSSSINNShe
Miami33139 editing restrictionAmend : Tothwolf10:44, 24-Aug-201014:45, 4-Sep-201011Passed90112026SISNNSSSASSSSINNShe
JBsupreme editing restrictionAmend : Tothwolf10:44, 24-Aug-201014:45, 4-Sep-201011Passed80112026SISNNSSSASSSINNShe
Lightmouse is permitted to use automation as authorizedAmend : Date delinking21:23, 24-Aug-201013:45, 4-Sep-201011Failed44011216RIONNSOSOSSORNNKir
Lightmouse is permitted a one authorized automated task Amend : Date delinking15:36, 29-Aug-201013:45, 4-Sep-20106Passed80011216RISNNSSSSSSSRNNCor
Brews ohare indefinite general probationAmend : Speed of light02:07, 11-Aug-201016:10, 22-Aug-201012Failed45012027OOIINNSOSSOSONNKir
Brews ohare topic banned from all physics pagesAmend : Speed of light02:07, 11-Aug-201016:10, 22-Aug-201012Passed90012027SSIINNSSSSSSSNNSts
Betacommand authorized to operate bot for specific taskAmend : Betacommand 219:15, 29-Jul-201007:12, 31-Jul-20101Passed71012117RSINNSSSOSSSNNRog
Betacommand authorized to operate botAmend : Betacommand 217:26, 25-Jul-201007:12, 31-Jul-20106Failed43012117ROINNSSOOSSNNKir
Miacek topic ban liftedAmend : Eastern European mailing list (3)15:47, 5-Jul-201023:55, 20-Jul-201015Passed8009235SSINNSIISSSRRSSNNSts
Amendment 4 expires concurrently with remedy 4.2Amend : Speed of light14:11, 24-Jun-201020:08, 7-Jul-201013Passed70012027SSINNSISSSSNNSts
Biruitorul topic banned liftedAmend : Eastern European mailing list14:07, 24-Jun-201019:51, 2-Jul-20108Passed6009235ISSINNRISSRSSNNSts
Remedy 2 changedAmend : Tothwolf20:26, 19-Jun-201019:33, 2-Jul-201013Passed70011036ISSINNSISSSSNNRle
The words "such as Time Cube" are struckAmend : Pseudoscience22:59, 17-Jun-201019:11, 2-Jul-201015Passed70211035IASINNSISSSSASNNSts
Radeksz topic banned liftedAmend : Eastern European mailing list04:49, 9-Jun-201020:55, 21-Jun-201013Passed7008335ISSINNRISSSSRRSNNSts
Piotrus editing restriction amendedAmend : Eastern European mailing list18:40, 27-Apr-201000:43, 6-May-20108Passed6108265SISINIRSISOSRSINICor
TenmeiClarify : Tang Dynasty17:44, 27-Apr-201015:23, 4-May-20107Passed81010066SISINISSISSSSOINIRis
Altenmann - Removal of administrator permissions20:51, 10-Apr-201001:08, 13-Apr-20102Passed130015108SSSNSSSSSSSSSRNSRis
1. PHG's mentorship is renewedAmend : Franco-Mongol alliance22:56, 20-Mar-201020:39, 30-Mar-201010Passed70012227SSSNRSISRSSNIChl
2. PHG's topic ban is renewedAmend : Franco-Mongol alliance22:56, 20-Mar-201020:39, 30-Mar-201010Passed70012227SSSNRSISRSSNIChl
2.1 PHG new article restrictionAmend : Franco-Mongol alliance07:56, 21-Mar-201020:39, 30-Mar-201010Failed15112226OAONROIOROSNISir
1. Brews ohare topic ban modified23:53, 23-Mar-201020:13, 29-Mar-20106Passed101014028SOSNSSSISSSSSNISir
1.1 Brews ohare topic ban modified18:14, 24-Mar-201020:13, 29-Mar-20105Failed34014028OSNOISOOSNIChl
1.2 Brews ohare topic ban modified19:34, 25-Mar-201020:13, 29-Mar-20104Failed33014028SNSOIOOSNIChl
2. Brews ohare advocacy restrictions23:53, 23-Mar-201020:13, 29-Mar-20106Passed83114027SOSNASOOISSSSSNISir
Case accepted not openedA Nobody18:28, 16-Mar-201023:26, 19-Mar-20103Passed130013127RSSSNSSSSSISSSSSNISts
Shoemaker's Holiday and DurovaDurova and Shoemaker's Holiday03:52, 12-Mar-201004:51, 15-Mar-20103Passed80110515RSSNSRSASRRSSRSNIRog
1) Trusilver/Brews ohare unblockTrusilver's unblock of Brews ohare20:06, 7-Mar-201004:17, 15-Mar-20107Passed105015018OOSONSSSSOOSSSSSNISir
1.1. Trusilver admonished and warnedTrusilver's unblock of Brews ohare17:55, 12-Mar-201004:17, 15-Mar-20102Failed*103215017SSSSNOOSSSSOSAASNIChl
ArbCom EnforcementTrusilver's unblock of Brews ohare16:31, 12-Mar-201004:17, 15-Mar-20102Passed130015018SSSSNSSSSSSSSSNISir
1) Remedy 4 is in force until September 18, 2011Clarify : Ireland article names03:36, 23-Feb-201016:03, 5-Mar-201011Passed80010246ISINISSSSSSSRRNICor
2) De facto consensus notedClarify : Ireland article names03:36, 23-Feb-201016:03, 5-Mar-201011Passed80010246ISINISSSSSSSRRNICor
1) Herostratus strongly admonished02:59, 3-Mar-201015:15, 5-Mar-20103Passed100013037ISINSSSSSSSSSNIHer
1.1) Herostratus desysopped02:59, 3-Mar-201015:15, 5-Mar-20103Failed28013037IOINSOOOOOOOSNIHer
1.2) Herostratus temporarily desysopped02:59, 3-Mar-201015:15, 5-Mar-20103Failed09013037IOINOOOOOOOONIHer
2) Viridae admonished02:59, 3-Mar-201015:15, 5-Mar-20103Passed91013037ISINSSSOSSSSSNIHer
1) Topic ban narrowed (Radeksz)Amend : Eastern European mailing list (3)23:27, 9-Feb-201018:21, 13-Feb-20104Passed70110255ISIISISSSSARRSNISts
2) Topic ban narrowed (Martintg)Amend : Eastern European mailing list (3)23:27, 9-Feb-201018:21, 13-Feb-20104Passed70110255ISIISISSSSARRSNISts
Abd and William M. Connolley prohibited from interactingClarify : Abd-William M. Connolley02:19, 19-Jan-201023:49, 2-Feb-201015Passed60110525SRIRRSSSASRSRNIKir
Craigy144 desysoppedCraigy14417:40, 28-Jan-201020:42, 30-Jan-20102Passed110014038SSIISSSSSSSSSNIRog
1) Topic ban narrowedAmend : Eastern European mailing list21:19, 25-Jan-201011:12, 28-Jan-20103Passed90014128SISSSSSSRSSNISts
2) Tagging and categorizing of unreferenced Poland-related BLPs allowedAmend : Eastern European mailing list21:19, 25-Jan-201011:12, 28-Jan-20103Passed90014128SISSSSSSRSSNISts
Proxy authorizationAmend : Eastern European mailing list (2)07:50, 23-Jan-201011:11, 28-Jan-20105Passed81015118SSSSSSSORSNIKir
1) Exception to topic banAmend : Speed of light02:31, 19-Jan-201002:06, 27-Jan-20108Passed90015028SISSSSSSSSNIKir
2) Second exception to topic banAmend : Speed of light18:23, 22-Jan-201002:06, 27-Jan-20104Passed80015028SISSSSSSSNIRis
Summary motion in lieu of a full caseBLP deletions07:57, 21-Jan-201018:48, 22-Jan-20101Passed94115208ORSSSSSRASOSSOONSKir
Imposition of discretionary sanctionsAmend : Falun Gong14:28, 15-Jan-201007:18, 19-Jan-20104Passed90016029SISSSSSSSSIKir
Remedy 3.2 revisedClarify : Abd-William M. Connolley10:57, 1-Jan-201016:04, 10-Jan-20109Passed90013237SIRSSSISSSSRSIVas
  • Failed*: Although receiving enough supports to pass, the motion failed in favor of an alternative motion.


Arb activity

[edit]

The column headings, in table below, have the following meanings:

  • EM (eligible motions): The total number of motions for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of motions for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as inactive/away at the time of the motion's closing, and did not act on the motion (i.e. did not recuse. support, oppose or abstain) (count of "I"s); as a percentage of EM.
  • R (recused): The total number of motions for which this arb recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EM − I).
  • V (voted): The total number of motions this arb voted to support or oppose (count of "S"s or "O"s); as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • A (abstained): The total number of motions for which this arb abstained (count of "A"s), as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of motions for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as active at the time of the motion's closing, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • S (supported): The total number of motions this arb supported (count of "S"s); as a percentage of V.
  • O (opposed): The total number of motions this arb opposed (count of "O"s); as a percentage of V.
  • Offered: The total number of motions which this arb offered; as a percentage of the total number of motions.
Arb activity (2010) — motions
ArbEMI%R%V%A%DNA%S%O%Offered%
Carcharoth601220%715%3995%00%25%3179%821%23%
Cool Hand Luke601728%25%2561%25%1434%1976%624%58%
Coren601220%00%4390%00%510%3684%716%58%
FayssalF602440%13%720%13%2777%686%114%00%
Fritzpoll1200%217%660%00%440%6100%00%00%
Hersfold33618%00%1659%14%1037%1488%213%47%
Kirill Lokshin6000%813%4281%00%1019%3890%410%1017%
KnightLago60610%00%4176%00%1324%3585%615%00%
Mailer diablo6035%12%3766%12%1832%3081%719%00%
Newyorkbrad6012%00%4373%47%1220%3786%614%12%
Risker60813%24%3162%36%1632%2684%516%35%
Rlevse5100%12%3774%00%1326%2773%1027%12%
Roger Davies6000%1118%3980%00%1020%3487%513%712%
Shell Kinney6012%1220%3370%24%1226%2988%412%35%
SirFozzie6000%35%4579%24%1018%3884%716%712%
Steve Smith571425%716%2981%00%719%2793%27%1118%
Vassyana200%00%150%00%150%1100%00%12%
Wizardman333194%00%2100%00%00%2100%00%00%

Cases

[edit]
  • Legend: Ac=Active, R=Recused, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible, Drafter = the poster of the first draft on the case's "Proposed decision" page.
  • Publicly heard cases: 12; average duration: 55 days; decided: 12 (100%); dismissed: 0 (0%).

Involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Publicly heard cases involving 2010 arbs only
CaseOpenedClosedDaysDispAcRIMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizDrafter
Stevertigo 229-Sep-201023-Oct-201024Decided12027INNINNKir
Climate change13-Jun-201014-Oct-2010123Decided8335RINNIIRRNNNew
Race and intelligence7-Jun-201024-Aug-201078Decided10226INNIRRNNCor
Transcendental Meditation movement18-Feb-20106-Jun-2010108Decided11036IINNINNRog
Russavia-Biophys6-Apr-201023-May-201047Decided9055IINNIIINNShe
Gibraltar11-Mar-201011-May-201061Decided8255IINIRIRINNNew
Alastair Haines 218-Apr-20108-May-201020Decided10056IINIIINNNew
Asgardian19-Feb-201010-Apr-201050Decided14028NINIKni
ChildofMidnight21-Feb-20109-Mar-201016Decided11146IRININICor
Chabad movement9-Jan-201013-Feb-201035Decided12057IIIININew
MZMcBride 219-Jan-201011-Feb-201023Decided12147IRIINIRog

Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Publicly heard cases Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
CaseOpenedClosedDaysDispAcRIMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirSteStsVasWizDrafter
Tothwolf15-Nov-200925-Jan-201071Decided90105IIIIIIIIIISte

Arb activity

[edit]

Legend

[edit]

The column headings, in the two tables below, have the following meanings:

  • EC (eligible cases): The total number of cases for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • Inactive: The total number of cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as inactive/away (count of empty cells); as a percentage of EC.
  • Recused: The total number of cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EC − Inactive).
  • Drafted: The total number of cases for which this arb posted the first draft of the case's "Proposed decision" page; as a percentage of the total number of cases decided.

Arb activity (2010)

[edit]
Arb activity (2010) — cases
ArbECInactive%Recused%Drafted%
Carcharoth12433%00%00%
Cool Hand Luke12542%343%00%
Coren1218%00%217%
FayssalF121083%00%00%
Fritzpoll3133%00%00%
Hersfold7571%00%00%
Kirill Lokshin1218%19%18%
KnightLago12433%00%18%
Mailer diablo12325%00%00%
Newyorkbrad1200%00%433%
Risker12217%110%00%
Rlevse12217%00%00%
Roger Davies1200%18%217%
Shell Kinney1218%00%18%
SirFozzie1200%18%00%
Steve Smith12650%233%00%
Vassyana100%00%00%
Wizardman55100%000%

Arb activity (departing 2009)

[edit]
Arb activity (departing 2009) — cases
ArbECInactive%Recused%Drafted%
FloNight00000%
Stephen Bain100%00%18%

Proposals

[edit]
  • Legend: S=Support, O=Oppose, A=Abstain, Ac=Active, R=Recused, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible. An "S1" indicates the first supporting vote. The numbers in the second set of arb columns give the length of time (rounded to the nearest day) between the first action (support, oppose or abstain) on this proposal and this arb's action.
  • Proposals: 370; passed: 287 (78%); failed: 83 (22%).

For cases involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Case proposals for cases involving 2010 arbs only
Stevertigo 2 - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=2)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Verifiability, reliable sources, and original researchP1Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
Accuracy of sourcingP1APassed10007SISSNNSSS1SSSSINN0010001010
Edit-warringP2Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
Violation of policyP3Passed10016SISANNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
RecidivismP4Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
Previous sanctionsF1Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
Stevertigo's editingF2Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
Stevertigo's edit summariesF3Passed9026SISANNS1ASSSSSSINN00101020010
Stevertigo's use of sourcesF4Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101010010
Stevertigo's approachF5Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00101020010
"Conceptualization"F6Failed5607OISONNS1OOOSSOSINN00101120010
Stevertigo bannedR1Passed10107OISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00201020010
Stevertigo to be placed on probationR2Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00201020010
Stevertigo required to cite sourcesR3Passed11007SISSNNS1SSSSSSSINN00201020010
Climate change - Proposals (AC=8, R=3, I=3)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Purpose of WikipediaP1Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Role of the Arbitration CommitteeP2Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
User ConductP3Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Collective behavior of blocs of editorsP4Passed7014SRAINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Collective behavior of blocs of editors (alternate)P4.1Failed*5014SRS1INNSIASISRRNN9000205
Wikipedia is not a battlegroundP5Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Casting aspersionsP6Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Neutrality and conflicts of interestP7Passed7105SROINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
AdvocacyP7.1Failed3405ORS1INNSIOSOIORRNN900150205
Biographies of living peopleP8Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Encyclopedic coverage of scienceP9Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Undue weightP10Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
SourcingP11Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Disruptive editingP12Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN241413300131914
Blocking and BanningP13Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN251413300131914
AdministratorsP14Failed*7005SRINNSISS1SISSRRNN2513300131314
Administrators working in contentious areasP14.1Passed8005SRSINNSISSSIS1SRRNN1211170001
Administrator involvement - generalP15Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN251413300131914
Involved administratorsP15.1Failed*6005SRSINNISSIS1SRRNN424307
Administrator involvement - enforcement mattersP16Passed7105SROINNSISS1SISSRRNN251413300131914
Administrator participation in enforcementP17Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN251413300131914
Right to vanishP18Failed*5305SROINNSIOSSIS1ORRNN1210170001
Right to vanishP18.1Passed8005SRS1INNSISSSISSRRNN11001602100
Detrimental editingP19Passed8005SRSINNS1ISSSISSRRNN11001602101
Conduct on arbitration pagesP20Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN10101502055
Battlefield editingP21Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN701101701
Enough is enoughP22Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN701101701
Evidence sub-pages in user spaceP23Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN11800302
Locus of disputeF1Failed*8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3344240434
Locus of disputeF1.1Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3344240434
Nature and extent of disputeF2Passed7105SRSINNOISS1SISSRRNN3344240494
Climate change probationF3Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3344240494
Disputes regarding administrator involvementF4Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3344240494
Sockpuppetry in the Climate Change topic areaF5Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN33442404939
Edit warring on Climate Change related articlesF6Failed*4224SRAINNAIOS1SIOSRRNN3344240694
Edit warring on Climate Change related articlesF6.1Passed7005SRSINNISS1SISSRRNN281190154
Personalization of disputeF7Passed8005SRSINNS1ISSSISSRRNN29002002161
William M. Connolley previously sanctioned and desysoppedF8.1Passed6024SRS1INNAISASISSRRNN32332302493
William M. Connolley has been uncivil and antagonisticF8.2Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3344240494
William M. Connolley has shown OwnershipF8.3Failed0805OROINNOIOOOIOORRNN29002002761
William M. Connolley BLP violationsF8.4Failed*5305SRS1INNOIOOSISSRRNN2900200261
William M. Connolley's edits to biographies of living personsF8.5Passed7105ORSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3600200150
Polargeo personal attacks and disruptionF9Failed1514ORAINNOIOOIOS1RRNN311020061
Polargeo's battlefield conductF9.1Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN215102317011
Thegoodlocust long-term disruptionF10.1Passed8005SRSINNS1ISSSISSRRNN31002052761
Thegoodlocust's battlefield conductF10.2Passed7005SRSINNISSSISS1RRNN20410221780
Marknutley disruptive behaviorF11Passed8005SRSINNS1ISSSISSRRNN31002052761
Lar blocks William M. ConnolleyF12Failed0533ORAINNOIOOAIOARRNN34442403194
Lar and Jehochman revert warF12.1Failed0624ORAINNOIOOOIOARRNN34442403194
RFC/U on LarF12.2Passed8005SRSINNS1ISSSISSRRNN31002052761
Lar's comments, actions, and mindsetF12.3Passed7014SRSINNS1ISASISSRRNN3100203227101
Stephan Schulz edits and admin actionsF13Failed0705ORINNOIOOOIOORRNN3442403194
Administrator participation by Stephan SchulzF13.1Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN32222202983
ChrisO's previous arbcom sanctionsF14.1Failed*4224ORSINNAISOAIS1SRRNN33222202913
ChrisO has made personal attacksF14.2Failed*6205ORSINNSISOSIS1SRRNN33222202913
ChrisO's battlefield conductF14.3Passed6005SRINNISSSIS1SRRNN164171105
Minor4th's battlefield conductF15Passed7005SRSINNISSSISS1RRNN27016292320
ATren's battlefield conductF16Passed6014SRSINNISASISS1RRNN270152922150
Hipocrite's battlefield conductF17Passed6014SRSINNISASISS1RRNN27015282210
Cla68's battlefield conductF18Passed6014SRSINNISSSIAS1RRNN26029332200
Scjessey's battlefield conductF19Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN26414272100
Scjessey's voluntary editing restrictionF19.1Passed6005SRINNISSSIS1SRRNN81094010
GregJackP's battlefield conductF20Passed7005SRSINNISSSISS1RRNN24213262030
A Quest For Knowledge's battlefield conductF21Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN225102418011
KimDabelsteinPetersen's battlefield conductF22Passed6014SRSINNISASIS1SRRNN17114171105
Verbal's battlefield conductF23Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN159216903
ZuluPapa5's battlefield conductF24Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN8298200
JohnWBarber's battlefield conductF25Failed4305ORSINNISOOISS1RRNN60711940
JohnWBarber's battlefield conductF25.1Passed7005SRS1INNISSSISSRRNN1023000
FellGleaming's battlefield conductF26Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN3044601
Discretionary sanctionsR1Failed3505OROINNOIOS1SIOSRRNN35223602273
Discretionary sanctionsR1.1Failed4405ORSINNS1IOSOIOSRRNN33003411251
Climate change: discretionary sanctionsR1.2Passed6105SROINNISSSIS1SRRNN8299307
Climate change sanctions noticeboard supersededR2Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3422360273
Scope of topic bansR3.1Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN211623016010
Appeal of topic bansR3.2Failed*7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN21323016010
Appeal of topic bansR3.2.1Passed7005SRSINNISS1SISSRRNN2132301619
Administrators who participate in Arbitration and Community Sanction enforcementR4.1Passed7005SRSINNSISS1SISRRNN342236022
Use of blogsR4.2Failed*7105SRSINNSISS1SIOSRRNN34223602212
Use of blogs and self-published sourcesR4.2.1Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1371413701
Project-wide policies remain in effectR4.3Passed7005SRSINNSISS1SISRRNN342236022
Biographies of Living PersonsR4.4Passed7005SRSINNSISS1SISRRNN342236022
Administrators, Checkusers, and the Climate change topic areaR4.5Passed7005SRSINNSISS1SISRRNN342236022
Deletion of evidence sub-pagesR4.6Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN148150902
William M. Connolley bannedR5.1Failed0805OROINNOIOOOIOORRNN36443804224
William M. Connolley topic-banned (Climate Change)R5.2Failed2314ROINNS1IOAIOSRRNN003438180
William M. Connolley topic-banned (BLP)R5.3Failed4205RS1INNSIOSIOSRRNN003438180
William M. Connolley restrictedR5.4Failed1505ROINNOIOS1IOORRNN003438181
William M. Connolley asked to disengageR5.5Failed0514ROINNOIOAIOORRNN00340180
William M. Connolley topic-bannedR5.6Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491520902
Polargeo admonishedR6.1Failed1305RINNOIOIOS1RRNN035181
Polargeo asked to disengageR6.2Failed1414ROINNS1IOAIOORRNN003435181
Polargeo topic-bannedR6.3Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491517902
Thegoodlocust bannedR7Failed2414ARS1INNOIOOIOSRRNN33003411181
Thegoodlocust topic banned (climate change)R7.1Failed3205RINNS1IOSIOSRRNN03435181
Thegoodlocust indefinitely banned (climate change)R7.2Failed3305RSINNS1IOSIOORRNN0034351821
Thegoodlocust topic-bannedR7.3Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491517902
Marknutley bannedR8.1Failed0414ARINNOIOIOORRNN33011181
Marknutley topic banned (climate change)R8.2Failed4205RSINNS1IOSIOSRRNN003435181
Marknutley topic banned (climate change)R8.3Failed3305RSINNS1IOSIOORRNN0034351821
Marknutley withdraws by mutual consentR8.4Failed2305RINNS1IOSIOORRNN03311180
Marknutley topic-banned (BLP)R8.5Failed3305RS1INNOIOSIOSRRNN003435181
Marknutley topic-bannedR8.6Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491517902
User:Lar and User:Jehochman admonishedR9Failed0805OROINNOIOOOIOORRNN35223602203
Lar's May 18 block of William M. Connolley affirmed; 2over0 strongly admonishedR9.1Failed1705OROINNOIOOOIOS1RRNN36443804224
Lar is an uninvolved admin but advisedR9.2Failed3414ORS1INNOIOAOISSRRNN381135036192
Lar asked to disengageR9.3Failed1314ROINNS1IAIOORRNN0035181
Stephan Schulz is an involved administratorR10Failed2414ARS1INNOIOOIOSRRNN3522360203
Stephan Schulz administrator participationR10.1Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN35223602203
Stephan Schulz asked to disengageR10.2Failed1514OROINNS1IOOIAORRNN3300340181
ChrisO banned from Climate Change article for six monthsR11.1Failed2505RS1INNOIOOOIOSRRNN223603203
ChrisO banned from BLPs for one yearR11.2Failed2505RS1INNOIOOOIOSRRNN223603203
ChrisO restricted to one accountR11.3Failed0505ROINNOIOOIORRNN003401
ChrisO instructedR11.4Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN3300340111
ChrisO asked to disengageR11.5Failed1414ROINNS1IOAIOORRNN003435181
ChrisO topic-bannedR11.6Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491517902
Minor4th topic-bannedR12Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491517902
ATren topic-bannedR13Passed6014SRSINNISASIS1SRRNN1491517902
Hipocrite topic-bannedR14Passed6014SRSINNISASIS1SRRNN1491517902
Cla68 topic-bannedR15Passed4024SRSINNISAIAS1RRNN126131400
Scjessey's topic ban (remedies)R16Failed*6005SRSINNISSSIS1RRNN126131470
Scjessey's voluntary editing restrictionR16.1Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN9111012401
GregJackP topic-bannedR17Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN1491517902
A Quest For Knowledge topic-bannedR18Passed6014SRSINNISASIS1SRRNN1491517902
KimDabelsteinPetersen: topic-bannedR19Failed4305ORS1INNISSSIOORRNN8078088
KimDabelsteinPetersen's voluntary editing restrictionR19.1Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN0020000
Verbal topic-bannedR20Passed6014SRSINNISASIS1SRRNN1491517902
ZuluPapa5 topic-bannedR21Passed7005SRSINNISSSIS1SRRNN82910300
JohnWBarber topic-bannedR22Passed5014SRSINNISAISS1RRNN233400
FellGleaming topic-bannedR23Passed6005SRSINNISSIS1SRRNN354601
Enforcement by blockE1Passed7005SRSINNSISS1SISRRNN3522360293
Uninvolved administratorsE2Failed0433ORAINNIOAOIOARRNN35236029353
Involved administratorsE2.1Passed6005SRSINNISS1ISSRRNN517054
LoggingE3Passed8005SRSINNSISS1SISSRRNN352236029353
Race and intelligence - Proposals (AC=10, R=2, I=2)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
PillarsP1Passed10006SSS1INNSISSRSSSSRNN12002029322729327
Original researchP2Passed10006SSS1INNSISSRSSSSRNN12002029322729327
Primary sourcesP3Failed3425AAS1INNOIOSROOSRNN120020293229327
Correct use of sourcesP3.1Passed9006S1SINNSISSRSSSSRNN018172014171910
Self-published sourcesP4Failed4606SOS1INNOISOROOOSRNN122202029322729327
MediationP5Passed10006SSS1INNSISSRSSSSRNN12002029322729327
AdvocacyP6Passed10006SSS1INNSISSRSSSSRNN12002029322729327
Single issue editorsP7Failed4606SOS1INNOIOSROOOSRNN121302029322710327
Single purpose accountsP7.1Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN211019221702212
DecorumP8Passed9006S1SINNSISSRSSSSRNN0108172019171910
Lengthy evidence and sub-pagesP9Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN202253041
Tag-team editingP10Passed6034ASINNAISARSS1SSRNN202143041
Focus of the dispute (1)F1Failed4606OOS1INNOIOSRSOOSRNN323303233323131327
Locus and focus of disputeF1.1Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN252543041
Focus of the disputeF2Failed2715OOS1INNOIOSROOOARNN12002033323131327
Focus of the disputeF2.1Failed3606OOINNOIOSRSOOS1RNN10111011109990
Editor behaviorF3Failed2806OOS1INNOIOOROOSORNN12802033323131327
Informal mediationF4Passed10006SSS1INNSISSRSSSSRNN12002033323131327
Mathsci (conduct)F5Failed*7206OSINNSISORSS1SSRNN712754042
Mathsci (conduct)F5.1Passed8006S1SINNSISSRSSSRNN00010010
David.Kane (conduct)F6Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN013665052
Captain Occam (conduct)F7Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN252654041
Mikemikev (conduct)F8Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN41411109090
Source probationR1Failed1906OOS1INNOIOOROOOORNN12202033323131327
Editors remindedR2Failed1906OOS1INNOIOOROOOORNN1213020333231313229
Topic restrictions (1)R3Failed1906OOS1INNOIOOROOOORNN12002033323131327
Topic restrictions (2)R3.1Failed1715OAINNOIOOROOOS1RNN521427262524250
Topic bans on race-related articlesR4Failed2606S1INNOIOOROOOSRNN08212019181916
Discretionary sanctionsR5Failed*6215OAINNS1ISSRSSOSRNN12301312118119
Editors reminded and discretionary sanctionsR5.1Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN202654041
Mathsci topic-banned by mutual consentR6Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN401442040
Mathsci topic-banned and cautionedR6.1Failed0306OINNOIRORNN000
David.Kane topic-bannedR7Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN101432030
Captain Occam topic-bannedR8Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN141432030
Mikemikev site-banned and thereafter topic-bannedR9Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN101432030
Evidence sub-pages (remedy)R10Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN201654041
EnforcementE1Failed4406OS1INNOIOSRSOSRNN330323332313229
Enforcement of topic-bans by blockE2Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN141432030
Review of topic-bansE3Passed9006SSINNSISSRSS1SSRNN141432030
Transcendental Meditation movement - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=3)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Purpose of WikipediaP1Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Neutral point of view and verifiabilityP2Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Neutrality and conflicts of interestP3Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Neutrality, verifiability and appropriate weightP4Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Neutrality and sourcesP5Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Use of primary and secondary sourcesP6Failed4025AIINNSSSS1AINN534806
Accuracy of sourcingP7Passed8006SIINNSSSSS1SSINN66348063
Academic inquiry, article claims and appropriate weightP8Failed3335OIINNAOOASS1SAINN44817110171
Decorum and assumptions of good faithP9Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Peremptory reversion or removal of sourced materialP10Passed7006SIINNSSSS1SSINN6634063
Consensus buildingP11Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Feuds and quarrelsP12Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Single purpose accountsP13Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Avoiding apparent improprietyP14Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
RecidivismP15Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN4481711510171
Off-wiki communicationP16Passed8006SIINNSSSSS1SSINN66346063
Off-wiki conductP17Passed8006SIINNSSSSS1SSINN66346063
Locus of disputeF1Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN8481811510171
BackgroundF2Failed5506OIINNOOOSSSS1OSINN8481811510171
BackgroundF2.1Passed10006SIINNSSSS1SSSSSINN6261701300160
FladrifF3Passed10006SIINNSSSSSSS1SSINN8481811510171
Sockpuppetry, meatpuppetry, and collusionF4Passed9006SIINNSSSSSSS1SINN848181151017
Tuckerj1976F5Passed9016SIINNSSSASSS1SSINN8481811510171
All parties instructedR1Passed8016SIINNSSSSSS1SAINN17221811510171
Editors remindedR2Passed8016SIINNSSSSSS1SAINN17221811510171
Discretionary sanctionsR3Passed9006SIINNSSSSSS1SSINN17221811510171
Guidance for uninvolved administratorsR4Passed7006SIINNSSSSS1SINN2730202
Periodic review by ArbComR5Passed5044AIINNAAASSS1SSINN17221811510171
Fladrif strongly admonished and restrictedR6Passed9006SIINNSSSSSS1SSINN17221811510171
Enforcement by blockE1Passed8016SIINNSSASSS1SSINN17221811510171
Russavia-Biophys - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=2)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Purpose of WikipediaP1Passed9007SSSINNSISSS1SSNN134460022
Editorial processP2Passed9007SSSINNSISSS1SSNN134460022
Neutral point of viewP3Passed9007SSSINNSISSS1SSNN134460022
National and territorial disputes or similar conflictsP4Passed9007SSSINNSISSS1SSNN134460022
DecorumP5Passed9007SSSINNSISSS1SSNN134460022
RecidivismP6Passed9007SSSINNSISSS1SSNN134460022
Locus of disputeF1Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
User conduct in this topic areaF2Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Battlefield mentalityF3Passed7016SSINNSIASS1SSNN14460022
Personal information and communicationsF4Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Battlefield mentalityF5Passed7016SSINNSIASS1SSNN14460022
Edit warringF6Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Personal informationF7Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Edit warringF8Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Combative editingF9Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Battlefield mentalityF10Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Edit warringF11Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Battlefield mentalityF12Passed7016SSINNSIASS1SSNN14460022
Edit warringF13Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Russavia restrictedR1Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Russavia admonishedR2Passed7016SSINNSISAS1SSNN14460022
Biophys topic bannedR3Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Biophys restrictedR4Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Vlad fedorov topic bannedR5Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Vlad fedorov admonishedR6Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Ellol topic bannedR7Passed7016SSINNSIASS1SSNN14460022
YMB29 topic bannedR8Passed7016SSINNSIASS1SSNN14460022
Editors remindedR9Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Enforcement by blockE1Passed8007SSINNSISSS1SSNN14460022
Gibraltar - Proposals (AC=8, R=2, I=5)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Purpose of WikipediaP1Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
Conduct and decorumP2Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
ConsensusP3Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
Neutral point of viewP4Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
Fact versus opinionP5Passed7014AISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
National and territorial disputes and similar conflictsP6Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
Anonymity and conflicts of interestP7Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015800350
Locus of disputeF1Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015801350
User conduct on GibraltarF2Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015801350
GibnewsF3Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Justin A KuntzF4Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
The Red Hat of Pat FerrickF5Failed4405SIOINIROIOSS1RSOINN101418207350
EcemamlF6Passed5124SISINIROIASS1RSAINN10151807351
Discretionary sanctionsR1Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Appeal of discretionary sanctionsR2Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Gibnews topic-bannedR3Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Gibnews topic-bannedR3.1Failed*8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Gibnews warnedR4Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Justin A Kuntz topic-bannedR5Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807351
The Red Hat of Pat Ferrick admonishedR6Failed4405SIOINIROIOSS1RSOINN101418207350
EcemamlR7Failed3414SIOINIROIOAS1RSOINN10151807350
EcemamlR7.1Passed7105SISINIROIS1SSRSSINN03606011
Editors remindedR8Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Conflicts of interestR9Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807350
Enforcement of discretionary sanctionsE1Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807361
Enforcement of decision sanctionsE2Passed8005SISINIRSIS1SSRSSINN1015807361
Alastair Haines 2 - Proposals (AC=10, R=0, I=5)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Purpose of WikipediaP1Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
The Wikipedia modelP2Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Editorial processP3Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Legal threatsP4Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Perceived legal threatsP5Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Legal threats against the Wikimedia FoundationP6Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Discussions and usernamesP7Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Repetition of improper conductP8Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Prior arbitration caseF1Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Continuing legal threatsF2Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Legal threats during this arbitration caseF3Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Alastair Haines and WikipediaF4Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Other issuesF5Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Alastair Haines bannedR1Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Alastair Haines return to editingR2Passed8006SISINISSIS1SSSINN00110000
Courtesy blanking and disengagementR3Passed8106SISINISSIS1SOSSINN001100100
Asgardian - Proposals (AC=14, R=0, I=2)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Edit warring is prohibitedP1Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
Editorial processP2Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
Article ownershipP3Passed9017ANSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
Edit summariesP4Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
Editor decorumP5Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
RecidivismP6Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
Past caseF1Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
Edit-warringF2Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI3400502030
Edit summariesF3Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI2400502030
IncivilityF4Passed10008SNSSS1SSISSSSNI3400502030
Asgardian bannedR1Passed9108ONSSS1SSISSSSNI3400502030
ChildofMidnight - Proposals (AC=11, R=1, I=4)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Casting aspersionsP1Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0231132413
Vested contributorsP2Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0231132413
Fair criticismP3Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0231132413
Purpose of WikipediaP4Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0231132413
User conductP5Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0231132413
Wikipedia is not a battlegroundP6Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0231132413
ChildofMidnightF1Failed3706IROINIOSOS1SOOOONI0133122313
Past sanctionsF2Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0133122313
Request for CommentF3Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0133122313
ChildofMidnight's reaction to the Request for CommentF4Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0133122313
ChildofMidnight's historyF5Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0133122313
ChildofMidnight's dealings with criticismF6Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0133122313
ChildofMidnight bannedR1Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0122121332
ChildofMidnight restrictedR2Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0122121332
Enforcement by blockE1Passed10006IRS1INISSSSSSSSSNI0122121332
Chabad movement - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=5)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Purpose of WikipediaP1Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
Neutral point of view and undue weightP2Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
DecorumP3Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
ConsensusP4Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
Role of the Arbitration CommitteeP5Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
Locus of disputeF1Passed9016ISIISISSSS1SSSANI1011200010
Content disputesF2Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
User conductF3Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
Editors remindedR1Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
Editors encouragedR2Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
Future proceedingsR3Passed10007ISIISISSSS1SSSSNI1011200010
MZMcBride 2 - Proposals (AC=12, R=1, I=4)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirStsVasWiz
Administrator conductP1Passed12007IRSISISSSSSSS1SSSNI103345340101
Return of access levelsP2Passed12007IRSISISSSSSSS1SSSNI103345340101
RecidivismP3Passed11016IRSISISSSSSSS1SSANI103345340101
Disruption to prove a pointP4Passed12007IRSISISSSSSSS1SSSNI153345340101
VandalismP5Passed11016IRSISISSSSASS1SSSNI113345340101
Serious accusationsP6Passed6064IRSISIAAAAASS1SASNI103345340101
Derogatory remarksP7Failed4445IRSISIOOAAASS1OAONI106545340101
MZMcBride's editing historyF1Passed12007IRSISISSSSSSS1SSSNI103345340101
MZMcBride's role in an "experiment"F2Passed12007IRSISISSSSSSS1SSSNI103345340101
MZMcBride's sockpuppetry postingF3Passed9216IRSIOISSSSASS1SSONI103345340101
MZMcBride and ToolserverF4Passed11016IRSISISSSSASS1SSSNI103345340101
MZMcBride's judgmentF5Passed11016IRSISISSSSSSS1SSANI103345340101
Durova's commentariesF6AFailed5616IRSIS1IOOOOASOSOSNI102455345240
Durova's commentariesF6BFailed5526IRSISIOOOOASS1SOANI103555340151
MZMcBride's administrator statusR1Failed*11107IRSIOISSSSSSS1SSSNI103445340101
MZMcBride's administrator statusR1.1Failed21007IROIOIOOOSOOOOS1ONI103445341101
MZMcBride's administrator statusR1.2Passed11007IRSIS1ISSSSSSSSSNI10234534110
MZMcBride's administrator statusR1.3Failed*7407IROISISOSSOSOSS1NI00234423000
MZMcBride admonishedR2Passed11016IRSISISSSSSSS1SSANI103445340101
MZMcBride admonishedR2.1Passed6226IRISISASSOSAOS1NI0234423040
Durova cautionedR3Failed5616IRSIS1IOOOOASOSOSNI102455345140
Toolserver accessR4Failed4616IRS1IOIOOOAOSOSSNI03233423344

Proposals: 347; passed: 266 (77%); failed: 81 (23%).

For cases involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Proposals for cases involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
Tothwolf - Proposals (AC=9, R=0, I=10)DispSOAMCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirSteStsVasWizCarChlCorFayFriHerKirKniMaiNewRisRleRogSheSirSteStsVasWiz
HarassmentP1Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
HoundingP2Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
Dealing with harassmentP3Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
Conflicts of interestP4Passed5034SIIIAIISAIIAISS1ISI115113101
Handling conflicts of interestP5Passed6024SIIIAIISAIISISS1ISI115113101
Fait accompliP6Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
Deletion best practicesP7Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
DecorumP8Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
Casting aspersionsP9Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI115113101
Deletion nominationsF1Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI141152013101
Deletion nominations and harassmentF2Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI141152013101
Deletion nominationsF3Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI141152013101
Deletion nominations and harassmentF4Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI141152013101
DecorumF5Failed1615OIIIOIIOOIIOIOS1IAI141152013101
DecorumF5.1Passed6115SIIIS1IISAIISISSIOI130141912524
Allegations against other editorsF6Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI141152013101
DecorumF7Passed8005SIIISIISSIISISS1ISI141152013101
Tothwolf restrictedR1Passed6024SIIISIISSIISIAS1IAI141152015101
Tothwolf restrictedR1.1Failed*5124OIIIS1IISSIISIAAISI1401419151425
JBsupreme warnedR2Passed5034SIIISIISAIISIAS1IAI143152015101
Miami33139 and JBsupreme remindedR3Passed6115SIIISIISAIISISS1IOI141152015101
Editors remindedR4Passed6024SIIIAIISAIISISS1ISI141152015101
Enforcement by blockE1Passed6115SIIISIISSIISIAS1IOI141152015101

Proposals: 23; passed: 21 (91%); failed: 2 (9%).

  • Failed*: Although receiving enough supports to pass, the proposal failed due either to preferential or conditional voting.

Arb activity

[edit]

Legend

[edit]

In the two tables below, the column headings have the following meanings:

  • EP (eligible proposals): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as inactive/away (count of "I"s); as a percentage of EP.
  • R (recused): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EP − I).
  • V (voted): The total number of proposals this arb voted to support or oppose (count of "S"s or "O"s); as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • A (abstained): The total number of proposals for which this arb abstained (count of "A"s), as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as active, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • S (supported): The total number of proposals this arb supported (count of "S"s); as a percentage of V.
  • O (opposed): The total number of proposals this arb opposed (count of "O"s); as a percentage of V.
  • FS (first support): The number of times this arb was first to support the proposal, which is generally indicative of having drafted the proposal (count of "S1"s); as a percentage of total number of proposals drafted.
  • ATV (average (mean) time to vote), MTV (median time to vote): For all the proposals this arb acted on (i.e. supported, opposed, or abstained), the average (mean) and the median of the length of time (in days) between the first action on the proposal and this arb's action on the proposal.

Arb activity (2010)

[edit]
Arb activity (2010) — case proposals
ArbEPI%R%V%A%DNA%S%O%FS%ATVMTV
Carcharoth3704813%00%29692%93%175%25887%3813%41%12.010.0
Cool Hand Luke37010929%17166%5056%33%3741%4182%918%00%3.31.0
Coren370113%00%25671%62%9727%23391%239%4412%4.02.0
FayssalF37034593%00%1248%28%1144%1192%18%00%1.21.0
Fritzpoll562341%00%33100%00%00%2988%412%31%0.30.0
Hersfold1249073%00%3191%39%00%3097%13%21%2.01.0
Kirill Lokshin370236%267%22570%62%9028%18180%4420%318%3.92.0
KnightLago37019653%00%16595%42%53%15091%159%113%4.74.0
Mailer diablo3707119%00%27592%31%217%22080%5520%00%16.115.0
Newyorkbrad37000%00%32889%3810%41%29289%3611%9425%6.71.0
Risker370349%3912%26188%134%238%24393%187%10%7.13.0
Rlevse37015742%00%15472%00%5928%14292%128%41%5.43.0
Roger Davies37000%267%27279%41%6820%22081%5219%9726%7.32.5
Shell Kinney370236%00%34198%51%10%30489%3711%4211%5.52.0
SirFozzie37000%13436%20788%115%188%19494%136%31%2.11.0
Steve Smith37010929%17366%6877%56%1517%6596%34%21%1.11.0
Vassyana2300%00%2087%313%00%1785%315%00%1.31.0
Wizardman8282100%00000000%

Arb activity (departing 2009)

[edit]
Arb activity (departing 2009) — case proposals
ArbEPI%R%V%A%DNA%S%O%FS%ATVMTV
FloNight000000000
Stephen Bain2300%00%2296%14%00%22100%00%2191%0.20.0
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Statistics_2010&oldid=1145982996"