Talk:Treble clef

While the difference between this and the G clef is one that must be made clear, I'm seeing a lot of dulication between the two pages. I'm opening the pondering of a merge ... -- Tarquin 20:42 Sep 18, 2002 (UTC)

Seems reasonable, as the G clef has very rarely been used as anything other than a treble clef. The only problem is that the merged article would have to live under the less common name of G clef because while all treble clefs are G clefs, not all G clefs are treble clefs. If you're going to do this, you might think about doing the same with bass clef and F clef - the F clef moves about a bit more than the G clef, but the two are still virtually synonymous these days. --Camembert

hmmm... tricky. I say we mull on it ... no rush :-) -- Tarquin

After a bit of mulling, I tried integrating all the clef articles into the single clef page. What do you think? -- Merphant

Start a discussion about improving the Treble clef page

Talk pages are where people discuss how to make content on Wikipedia the best that it can be. You can use this page to start a discussion with others about how to improve the "Treble clef" page.

Start a discussion