Draft talk:David M. Grobman
Add topic| This draft does not require a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Cannot find threads of previous discussions/questions
[edit]I cannot find threads of my discussions with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Theroadislong or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:J%C3%A9sk%C3%A9_Couriano. I also got a notification that David10244 mentioned me, but when I followed the link to the discussion page I could not find neither Aramhayr nor David10244 string (while searching).
I am sorry for raising up communication issues here, but I am really having hard time communicating in Wikipedia - it is not intuitive (to me). Can someone point me to instructions on how to find the threads above and in future communications?
I left some facts in Bio section that I would like to leave. However, I do not have any published sources of reference/verifications for those. Please let me know if there are other references that I can provide for verifications (for example title pages of dissertations - they are considered as manuscripts in Russia). If there is none then I'll remove the whole Bio section. Will that make the article approvable? Aramhayr (talk) 19:17, 8 November 2022 (UTC)
Explanations for resubmitting
[edit]I plan to resubmit the draft of the David Grobman article without changes, as I believe it now meets Wikipedia’s requirements following my November 2022 edits. To address the reviewers’ concerns: Verifiability: I added inline citations to reputable sources for all claims. Please identify any specific sources you consider unreliable or any statements lacking citations. After my edits, all potentially unsupported or "suspicious" facts were removed (you can verify this by comparing with the Russian version of the article, which retains the original content). Notability: This article concerns a deceased person, satisfying Wikipedia’s notability criteria for biographies. Corroboration: I recently learned that my draft was published unchanged as a Wikitia article: David M. Grobman on Wikitia. This demonstrates independent verification of the content’s suitability for an encyclopedia entry.
If you approve the article for publication, please advise how to proceed - whether by having Wikitia reference Wikipedia or another method to create a single, authoritative version.
P.S. I tried to send these explanations to AfC Help Desk, but got a error at submission: "sent to spam blacklist" or something. Aramhayr (talk) 05:52, 27 April 2026 (UTC)
- Draft-Class biography pages
- Draft-Class Soviet Union pages
- NA-importance Soviet Union pages
- WikiProject Soviet Union articles
- Draft-Class Jewish history-related pages
- NA-importance Jewish history-related pages
- WikiProject Jewish history articles
- Draft-Class mathematics pages
- NA-priority mathematics pages
- Draft-Class Technology pages
- WikiProject Technology articles