Edge Rewrite
Jump to content

// Workers AI · dad joke modeWhat did "We Had It All" data say to storage? Byte me.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

We Had It All
Studio album by
ReleasedAugust 1974
Recorded1973–1974
StudiosNova Studios, Marble Arch, London
Genres
Length34:37
LabelColumbia
ProducerDel Newman
Scott Walker chronology
Stretch
(1973)
We Had It All
(1974)
No Regrets
by
The Walker Brothers

(1975)
Singles from We Had It All
  1. "Delta Dawn" b/w "We Had It All"
    Released: July 1974

We Had It All is the tenth solo studio album by the American singer Scott Walker. It was released in August 1974 but was unsuccessful on the music charts. It was Walker's final solo album for ten years; in the interim Walker reformed The Walker Brothers for three albums, the last of which, 1978's Nite Flights, included his first original songs since his 1970 solo album 'Til the Band Comes In.

Four of the 10 songs on the album were written by Billy Joe Shaver and had previously appeared on Waylon Jennings's 1973 outlaw country album Honky Tonk Heroes, as had the title track. The album was recorded in August 1974 at Nova Studios, Marble Arch, London. The album was released as an LP in late 1974 and received generally negative reviews. The album was reissued and released on CD in 1997 by BGO Records coupled with Walker's ninth studio album 1973's Stretch. The artwork for the album was produced by Roslav Szaybo with photography from M. Joseph.

Critical reception

[edit]
Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllmusicStarStar[2]
Allmusic (Stretch/We Had It All)StarStar[3]

In a contemporary review of We Had It All, Sidney Nelson of the Bucks Examiner noted the "slightly world-weary touch" to Walker's voice but it also its power and tone, further praising the "most pleasing" self-produced album for containing "cleverly chosen" songs and expertly handled performances. "A singer I always felt deserved more solo success", the reviewer concluded, "Scott enhances that opinion with an LP of good easy listening."[4]

Retrospectively, Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic noted Walker's new focus on country music and felt that, despite being "still a little musically tentative" and lamenting the continued lack of original material, We Had It All is nonetheless the singer's "strongest record in years, since the country leanings are a welcome change of pace and he sings with authority throughout the record."[5] In an AllMusic review of the 1997 CD release which pairs We Had It All with its predecessor, Stretch (1973), Erlewine deemed both albums to be "slight collections of contemporary country-pop and folk-rock covers, produced in an anemic, bloodless fashion where the strings don't soar, they limp."[6]

Wilson Neate of Trouser Press similarly noted that, whereas Walker dabbled with country music on Stretch, he explored this direction further with We Had It All, "this time with a little more success". Neate deems both albums to be reasonably entertaining but noted that Walker was "going through the motions, refusing to challenge himself or his listener the way he did on his first four albums."[7]

Track listing

[edit]
Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Low Down Freedom"Billy Joe Shaver3:43
2."We Had It All"Donnie Fritts, Troy Seals3:29
3."Black Rose"Billy Joe Shaver3:16
4."Ride Me Down Easy"Billy Joe Shaver3:32
5."You're Young and You'll Forget"Jerry Reed2:27
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
6."The House Song"Robert H. Bannard, Paul Stookey3:44
7."What Ever Happened to Saturday Night"Randy Meisner, Don Henley, Glenn Frey, Bernie Leadon2:53
8."Sundown"Gordon Lightfoot4:49
9."Old Five and Dimers Like Me"Billy Joe Shaver2:58
10."Delta Dawn"Alex Harvey3:47

Release details

[edit]
Country Date Label Format Catalog
United Kingdom 1974 CBS Records Vinyl 80254
1997 BGO Records CD BGOCD358 Coupled with Stretch

References

[edit]
  1. Nelson, Sidney (October 18, 1974). "Turn Table". Evening Post. Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, England: 10. Retrieved May 28, 2026.
  2. Allmusic review
  3. Allmusic review
  4. Nelson, Sidney (October 25, 1974). "A Singer Who Seems to Have Seen It All". Bucks Examiner. Chesham, Buckingham, England: 15. Retrieved May 28, 2026.
  5. Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. "We Had It All Review by Stephen Thomas Erlewine". AllMusic. Retrieved May 28, 2026.
  6. Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. "Stretch/We Had It All Review by Stephen Thomas Erlewine". AllMusic. Retrieved May 28, 2026.
  7. Neate, Wilson. "Scott Walker". Trouser Press. Retrieved May 28, 2026.