Edge Rewrite
Jump to content

Talk:Gabe Mirkin

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 5 months ago by JaredMcKenzie in topic Vague overgeneralisation; no attributions?

Vague overgeneralisation; no attributions?

[edit]

Not a fan of the guy but this article comes across as a hit piece and the parts attacking him in the lede is too vague. Vague negatives but no attribution - and implied conclusion that he is mostly wrong? Yeah, he got a few things wrong but he was also right on quite a few things. The issue is that it makes it seem like he got everything wrong which is an over generalisation. It follows a false binary - medicine evolves; early or later revised studies are normal. Mirken at least corrected himself - which is a professional strength not a scandal. The lede should not editorialize or overgeneralize but fairly stick to neutral facts. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 22:51, 3 March 2026 (UTC)Reply