Talk:Scott Chisholm

Clean-up

Two of the entries are to deleted articles, but they technically meet MOS:DABRL as they are linked to a couple of articles. I was unsure whether the footballer should be the primary with this as Scott Chisholm (disambiguation) or if the links to del pgs should just be removed? Boleyn (talk) 20:35, 18 October 2009 (UTC)

• I've undeleted the out-of-process (& i'm pretty sure unjustified) deletion of the actor's bio, and made it a pretty decent stub. The actor amassed 8 credits in 10 years, but it's hard to say whether he's keeping just as busy making ads, or taking the long view and concentrating on his studies now that he's older.
  I'm not that impressed with the footballer (<<the report card on Scott Chisholm ... would probably have to read "could have done better">>, in part bcz he seems to have made his primary mark in North Australia and it's my impression that that state still stands in a decidedly unremarkable position relative to the others, despite presumed advancement since someone's mother had been the only married woman in Alice Springs, and since Alice Springs was remarkable for a mining prospectors' pub with a urinal running the length of the bar (making it feasible for the more recently successful patrons to buy and sell places to stand at the bar).
  But i know so little about Australia, and so much less about A-rules football, that i'll say only that i'd like to hear why the footballer might be clearly more notable than the other two contenders for the "base" title.
  --Jerzy•t 07:48, 20 October 2009 (UTC)