Talk:Rolly View

Former name of hamlet

An editor recently contributed, "Rolly View was initally incorporated as Rosenthal" with this reference. In reviewing the reference, the book indicates that "Rosenthal" was renamed to "Rolly View district". This article is about the "Hamlet of Rolly View", whereas the reference refers to the "Rolly View district". Unless one can confirm that the "Rolly View district" is what is now known as the "Hamlet of Rolly View", and not a larger rural area surrounding the hamlet, then the contribution is not relevant to the article in its current form. If it can be confirmed that the district surrounds the hamlet, the contribution would be relevant if the relationship between the district and hamlet is explained. Also note that what happened, according to the reference, is a renaming, not an incorporation. Hwy43 (talk) 04:10, 23 March 2011 (UTC)