Talk:Punch Powertrain

Tag explanation

Hi, I’m not sure how A7 and G11 apply here based on the reasons given by the nominator

A7 is deliberately a narrow criterion and applies where an article “does not indicate why its subject is important or significant.” Its threshold is considerably lower than determining whether a subject ultimately meets Wikipedia’s general notability guideline. In this case, the article did indicate the subject’s significance and was supported by multiple reliable, independent secondary sources providing substantial in-depth coverage.

I’m also unclear on the G11 tag. The article was written in an encyclopedic format and based on published sources. While individual passages can certainly be revised for neutrality, G11 is intended for articles that are blatantly promotional, rather than simply company articles that may need some copy editing.

If there were specific passages that were considered blatantly promotional it would be helpful to identify them so they can be addressed through editing rather than treating the entire article as meeting G11. AarvexSK (talk) 16:17, 1 September 2026 (UTC)