Talk:Mahendranath Ray

Neutral POV

User:Wisher08 has been editing the page to specifically make the article not from a neutral point of view.

Using language like "commendable," "very successful," "very bright," and "hugely learned and empathetic legal practitioner," etc., are plainly biased, are not encyclopedic, and are not appropriate to have on a Wikipedia page.

Further, it is not necessary to list every single exam the man ever took; every scholarship the man earned, etc.

His coverage of Mr. Roy's career is filled with unsupported claims such as: "represented many clients in many big cases in the Calcutta High court and other district courts, he earned the reputation of a hugely learned and empathetic legal practitioner, he was respected by both his colleagues and adversaries." This claim has sources provided, however, none of whom are supportive of the extremely bold claims being made.

I attempted to make changes to address these issues, and User:Wisher08 reverted it to the biased version he had made it earlier. I have noticed that biased, or over-the-top writing is a recurring issue in the articles that he writes, including in his talk page. This style of writing is inappropriate for Wikipedia, and should be removed in favor of a neutral point of view, per Wikipedia policy. AlmostHalfOkay (talk) 00:45, 4 June 2026 (UTC)