Edge Rewrite
// HTMLRewriter · presentation

This page was redesigned at the edge.

Cloudflare fetched the original article and streamed it through HTMLRewriter to apply an entirely new visual system without rebuilding the source page.

// request.cf · coarse context

A page that knows where it met you.

Only coarse request metadata is shown. This demo does not display or persist visitor IP addresses.

Country
US
Cloudflare location
CMH
Connection
HTTP/2
Language
Not provided

Ray ID: a2379a913b2f14c2

Jump to content

Talk:Elliot Murphy

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 9 months ago by ChrysGalley in topic Comments left by AfC reviewers

Comments left by AfC reviewers

[edit]
  • Comment: Thank you for tidying up the source notation, and I can see the submitting editor has done a lot of work on this article since August.
    Unfortunately I think this may have gone too far in the other direction. See WP:REFBOMB and the essay WP:THREE. Having a line of 9 references (and several of three) is unhelpful to the reader. The focus here is on good quality sources to either establish notability or to verify statements in the article, not on lots of them. It's also less important what the subject says, in terms of sourcing, more important about what other people are saying about him.
    In terms of notability, I am assuming the submitting editor is leaning on WP:ACADEMIC criteria number 1, if none of the other 7 applies. If so, then merely being cited isn't enough, ideally we would want a review or critique of his work. I imagine that will exist for ROSE, rather than just cited. Or perhaps a profile of his academic career by an independent source.
    ChrysGalley (talk) 21:20, 21 October 2025 (UTC)Reply
  • Comment: I can't see any sign that he passes WP:NPROF or WP:GNG Have any of his books been reviewed in reliable, independent publications (e.g. newspapers and academic journals)? If so, please add these book reviews as references. Please also see WP:REFB for instructions on converting your references from bare URLs to full citations. MCE89 (talk) 07:55, 17 August 2025 (UTC)Reply