Edge Rewrite
// HTMLRewriter · presentation

This page was redesigned at the edge.

Cloudflare fetched the original article and streamed it through HTMLRewriter to apply an entirely new visual system without rebuilding the source page.

// request.cf · coarse context

A page that knows where it met you.

Only coarse request metadata is shown. This demo does not display or persist visitor IP addresses.

Country
US
Cloudflare location
CMH
Connection
HTTP/2
Language
Not provided

Ray ID: a41396904b23e9de

Jump to content

Ozolua

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Okpame)

Ozolua
15th Oba of the Kingdom of Benin
Bronze relief of a standing royal figure in elaborate regalia
Bronze plaque identified as Ozolua preparing for war, Museum of Black Civilisations, Dakar
Oba of the Kingdom of Benin
Reignc. 1481 – c. 1504 in the traditional chronology; alternatively c. 1480 – c. 1517
CoronationUsama
PredecessorOlua, followed by an approximately three-year interregnum
SuccessorEsigie
BornOkpame (or Okpamen)
Diedc. 1503 – c. 1504 in the traditional chronology; possibly c. 1516 – c. 1517
Uzea kingdom
Cause of death
Killed during the Uromi campaign
Burial
Benin capital
Spouse
  • Egbe
  • Idia
  • Ohomwin
  • Eyowo
Issue
Regnal name
Ozolua n'Ibaromi ('Ozolua the Conqueror')
DynastyEweka dynasty
FatherEwuare

Ozolua, known as Okpame or Okpamen before taking the throne, was the fifteenth Oba ('king') of the Kingdom of Benin whose reign spanned the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries. Benin tradition remembers him by the name Ozolua n'Ibaromi (Ozolua the Conqueror). A son of Ewuare, he became king after the reign of Olua and an interregnum of roughly three years during which leading chiefs attempted to administer Benin without an Oba. Before becoming king, he had been involved in an earlier succession dispute in which traditions attribute to him the killing of Prince Owere, after which he was exiled to Ora town in present-day Owan West, Nigeria.

Military activity occupied much of Ozolua's reign. Campaigns were particularly frequent in Ishan, while traditions also associate him with warfare involving Owo, Ijebu, Uromi, Uzea kingdom, Iwu, Utekon village and other communities and rulers. Earlier accounts sometimes interpret literally the traditional claim that he fought or defeated two hundred opponents, whereas later writers have treated the number as a conventional expression for a large total. His reign is also associated with the extension of dynastic influence through sons and other royal figures connected with Idoani, Ora village, Okpe town, Owo, Aboh and other communities on the margins of Benin's political sphere. The earliest sustained relationship between Benin and Portugal is also associated with Ozolua's reign. João Afonso d'Aveiro reached Benin in 1485 or 1486, and both Portuguese documentation and Benin traditions connect the diplomatic and commercial exchanges that followed with Ozolua's court, although some modern reconstructions place the first Portuguese arrival somewhat earlier. Traditions further associate his son and eventual successor Esigie with Portuguese missionaries, instruction in the Portuguese language and Christianity, while also remembering Ozolua as suspicious of Esigie's relationship with the foreigners.

The chronology of Ozolua's final years is disputed. Historian Jacob Egharevba places Ozolua's last Uromi campaign around 1503 and dates Esigie's accession to 1504. Anthropologist Robert Elwyn Bradbury, however, regarded a chronology in which Esigie became king around 1517 as possible, though speculative, while art historian Barbara Winston Blackmun also dated Ozolua's reign to approximately 1480–1517. Traditions consistently describe Ozolua's death as violent and occurring during his final campaigning in the Uromi–Uzea region, but differ over whether dissatisfied soldiers poisoned or directly killed him, or whether betrayal enabled forces from Uzea to do so.

Background and accession

[edit]

Name, parentage and titles

[edit]

Historical accounts give Ozolua's name before accession as Okpame or Okpamen, while historian Jacob Egharevba records his royal name in the forms Ozolua or Ozoluwa.[1][2] Historian Robert Arthur Sargent calls him Prince Okpame Ozolua before his accession and describes him as a son of Ewuare and younger brother of Oba Ezoti.[3] Historian Alan Frederick Ryder likewise identifies Ozolua as Ewuare's youngest son.[4] Benin tradition associates him with the epithet Ozolua n'Ibaromi, which Egharevba renders as "Ozolua the Conqueror".[5] Historian Osemwegie Ebohon records the related form Ozolua Nibaromi Eko and also links Ozolua with the title Ogie Akpolokpolo, translated by Ebohon as "Emperor".[6] Ebohon identifies Ozolua as the first Oba to bear Ogie Akpolokpolo, while Egharevba states more broadly that the territorial expansion associated with Ozolua's reign led later Benin Obas to use the titles Oba Nokhua or Ogie-Akpolokpolo.[6][7]

Succession disputes before accession

[edit]

Following Ewuare's death, Sargent identifies Ewuare's eldest son Ezoti as the first prince chosen for the throne. Ezoti died soon after installation, and his son Owere was then nominated as successor. Sargent describes Ezoti and Owere as the first holders of the Edaiken ('crown prince') title who also belonged to the Uzama Nihinron ('kingmakers').[8] Traditions recorded by Sargent and Ebohon attribute Owere's death to Prince Okpame, who was himself seeking the throne.[3][9] Sargent further states that Owere's mother was killed alongside him while they were travelling to accept his nomination.[8] Ebohon places the killing at Esi village and describes Okpamen as Ezoti's brother and Owere's uncle.[2] Okpame was consequently expelled from Benin, with Sargent placing his exile at Ora village.[10][2]

The Uzama Nihinron next attempted to persuade Olua, another brother of Ezoti, to become king. Olua initially declined because he feared retaliation from Okpame. Attention then turned to Princess Edeloyo, a daughter of Ewuare, who accepted the nomination but was declared ineligible after what the tradition termed a "female complaint". Sargent treats as conjectural the possibility that fear of Okpame, rather than the stated reason, caused Edeloyo to withdraw.[8] Olua eventually accepted the throne and sent his youngest son to Eho town to guard the approaches to Benin in case Okpame attempted to return by force.[3] Sargent characterises Olua's reign as relatively peaceful and states that Okpame remained at Ora during this period while Iginua, Olua's son, held the Edaiken title.[10]

Interregnum and recall from Ora

[edit]

The succession again became uncertain after Olua died because several potential heirs had either died or been ruled ineligible.[11] In the absence of an Oba, senior members of the Uzama Nihinron attempted to govern Benin, an arrangement that Egharevba and later writers described as republican government.[1][12] Egharevba states that the arrangement lasted about three years but failed to preserve either authority throughout the country or obedience within the Benin capital. During the resulting disorder, he records that people from neighbouring villages and alien settlements entered the city and looted it.[1] Sargent similarly describes the system as a republican government led by the Uzama, with the Oliha functioning as president.[13] He interprets the experiment as an effort by the Uzama Nihinron to expand their own authority while reducing or abolishing the political authority of the Oba.[12] Sargent also links resistance to Okpame's return with his earlier involvement in the violent succession crisis.[11]

Anthropologists Peter M. Roese and Dmitri M. Bondarenko record a related narrative in which dissatisfaction with Olua led to an attempt to abolish the monarchy and govern through appointed rulers in both the Benin capital and the provinces. Under this version, Ozolua was offered the military position of Okhae Ighele ('youth leader') instead of the kingship, but rejected the arrangement. Acting on the advice of his wife Egbe, he withdrew to Ora village, which Roese and Bondarenko identify as his mother's community, and governed there. Roese and Bondarenko describe Elekidi of Ogbelaka, a warrior and military commander, as the principal appointed ruler, while a woman named Enae is said to have controlled the palace district of Ogbe. They state that after the established chiefs and elders lost effective control, the Ezomo and Iyase consulted an oracle, which instructed them to recall Ozolua.[14][a]

Egharevba states that Benin's chiefs and people invited the exiled Prince Okpame to return, occupy his ancestral throne and defend the country, but that he initially declined. They then sent the royal jester Akaromwon or Oden carrying a leather box that contained a house mouse and a bush mouse. Once released, the house mouse moved towards the house while the bush mouse ran into the bush, and tradition interprets their behaviour as persuading Okpame that he too should return to his proper home.[1] Roese and Bondarenko give a more elaborate form of the same recall narrative, stating that earlier delegations to Ora had been unsuccessful before the royal jester Oden volunteered to make another attempt.[16] Oden travelled with a bird called umobie, a house mouse and a country mouse and promised offerings at shrines if his mission ended safely. At Ozolua's court in Ora, Oden addressed the prince as though he were already king and relied on the traditional immunity enjoyed by royal jesters. When the animals were released, the bird flew into a tree, the house mouse moved towards the roof and the country mouse disappeared into the bush. Ozolua interpreted their behaviour as evidence that every creature recognised its proper destination and decided to return to the Benin capital.[17]

Coronation and consolidation

[edit]
European engraving showing palace compounds and a mounted royal procession in a large city.
European engraving of the Benin capital first published in 1668.

After assembling his followers, Okpame returned to the Benin capital, where he was welcomed and crowned at Usama under the royal name Ozolua.[1] Sargent describes the recall of Okpame from Ora as ending the republican experiment and identifies him as the fifteenth monarch of the Eweka dynasty.[13] Ebohon likewise states that the republican administration's inability to restore order prompted the palace chiefs to recall Okpamen from exile and crown him as Ozolua.[2] His accession did not immediately eliminate resistance either inside Benin or in nearby territories. Roese and Bondarenko state that opposing rulers continued to resist his kingship and that tradition attributes his eventual success to a combination of military action, political strategy and magical assistance.[17]

Among the earliest opponents remembered from this period was the Elekidi of Ogbelaka.[5][17] His wife Eyowo betrayed him, after which he was killed in battle. Ozolua married Eyowo but ordered her execution several weeks later because he feared that someone who had betrayed one husband could eventually betray another. Egbaen of Iwu village resisted for longer, and Ozolua was at one stage captured during the conflict and sought assistance from chiefs in the capital. Those chiefs demanded additional titles before intervening. Ozolua agreed, but after receiving their new honours they celebrated instead of immediately assisting him. Ozolua escaped, rebuilt his military forces, defeated Egbaen and ordered him beheaded.[5][17] Egharevba also identifies Ise of Utekon village as an opponent and states that Ozolua defeated him because Orimworia betrayed Ise.[5] Ozolua initially rewarded Orimworia, but later ordered his death after he boasted about the betrayal.[5]

Reign

[edit]

Chronology

[edit]

The arrival of the Portuguese provides the principal late-fifteenth-century chronological reference point for Ozolua's reign in Benin tradition.[18][19] Anthropologist Robert Elwyn Bradbury notes that both Egharevba's chronology and that of anthropologist Percy Amaury Talbot depend heavily on the tradition that Ozolua was the reigning Oba when the first European reached the Benin capital in 1485 or 1486. Although Bradbury considered the dates and genealogies of earlier rulers uncertain, he regarded the later fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries as more securely anchored because of European records.[18] Historian Robert Sydney Smith likewise uses the Portuguese contact of 1485 as the principal fixed chronological point for Ozolua and accepts Bradbury's view that the royal sequence from Ewuare through the sixteenth century broadly agrees with the available evidence.[19]

Egharevba places Ozolua's accession around 1481 and dates the beginning of the reign of Esigie, Ozolua's son and successor, to 1504.[20] Historian Flora Edouwaye Kaplan similarly gives approximately 1481–1504 for Ozolua's reign.[21] Sargent instead dates Esigie's rule to approximately 1509–1536, implying a later end to Ozolua's reign than in Egharevba's chronology.[22] Historian Adrian Hastings treats Ozolua as still ruling in 1514 and 1515 during diplomatic exchanges with Portugal and the arrival of Christian missionaries.[23] Blackmun dates Ozolua to approximately 1480–1517 and Esigie to approximately 1517–1550.[24] Bradbury examined Portuguese reports from 1516 and 1517 and argued that, if accurately interpreted, they probably indicate the death of a Benin ruler in late 1516 or early 1517.[25] He identified Ozolua's final campaign at Uromi as one possible explanation for the war mentioned in those Portuguese records and therefore suggested that Esigie may have acceded around 1517, while explicitly treating the reconstruction as speculative.[26]

Royal authority and administration

[edit]

Sargent interprets Ozolua's reign as a stage in limiting the political authority previously exercised by the Uzama Nihinron over royal succession.[27] In his interpretation, the Uzama had already departed from ordinary collateral succession when they nominated Owere, and Ozolua later sought to establish primogeniture as a regular principle of succession. Sargent argues that designating Ozolua's heir as Edaiken completed part of this institutional change and reduced the Uzama's earlier freedom to determine who would become the next Oba.[13] He further links the decline of the Uzama's practical political influence with the growth of the Eghaevbo, the town and palace chiefs, while noting that the Uzama preserved important ritual responsibilities in royal installation.[27] Even after much of their earlier influence over royal selection had declined, they continued to inaugurate new kings and receive the fees connected with installation.[28]

Brass royal head with a beaded crown and a high collar.
Sixteenth-century brass head of an Oba.

On the status of primogeniture in Ozolua's time, historian Nkiru Nzegwu states that the principle had not yet been formally established when Ozolua's sons entered their succession struggle.[29] Historian Kathy Curnow, however, presents Ogidogbo as Ozolua's recognised heir because primogeniture was already in effect.[30] Ebohon argues that earlier Benin succession did not consistently follow primogeniture and remained vulnerable to political intervention and competition within the palace.[2] Because Ozolua spent long periods campaigning away from the capital, senior officials assumed responsibility for administration in his absence.[31] Roese and Bondarenko identify his Iyase as Emovon, an orphan who eventually attained one of the kingdom's senior offices.[32] Although Emovon is not remembered as independently directing campaigns of the kind led by Ozolua, he and other senior officials handled state affairs during the Oba's extended absences from the capital.[31]

Sargent treats the reigns of Ewuare and Ozolua as part of a broader transformation in which Benin developed from a comparatively limited polity into a larger imperial system connected to regional and long-distance commerce.[33] He regards the growth of tributary relationships and the appointment of regional administrators as central to that process.[34] In Sargent's reconstruction, by approximately 1482–1509 Benin's influence reached northwards towards the Niger–Benue confluence and westwards towards the Ogun River. He describes the state as sufficiently centralised and militarily organised to maintain and expand this wider sphere of authority. Sargent also connects conquest with growing requirements for tribute and surplus production from incorporated communities. Although campaigns yielded enslaved captives, he notes that the available evidence does not permit a firm estimate of the extent to which slave labour contributed to production. In his interpretation, enslaved people formed part of royal tribute and redistribution within the Oba's patronage system rather than constituting an exclusively royal labour force.[35] Sargent additionally links military service to obligations imposed on the Igele age grade within the Otu system. He argues that the frequent warfare attributed to Ozolua increased military demands on this age grade and consequently increased pressure on the producing population.[36]

Military campaigns

[edit]

Warfare occupies a substantial place in Benin traditions concerning Ozolua's reign.[4][37] Ryder states that Ozolua kept Benin's armies in frequent service and was capable of undertaking two campaigns within one year. He also records at least one major defeat, while arguing that divisions among Ozolua's opponents, the strength of Benin forces and Ozolua's military reputation generally favoured him.[4] Egharevba states that Ozolua went to war against towns or villages at intervals of roughly six months and sometimes intentionally took relatively small forces because he wanted campaigns to remain difficult. According to Egharevba, Ozolua did not undertake a major expedition without his favoured general Laisolobi. Egharevba attributes at least two hundred victories to him and links the total with the epithet Ozolua n'Ibaromi.[5] Roese and Bondarenko caution that the number two hundred may operate symbolically in Benin tradition as an expression for a large quantity rather than a literal count.[38]

Brass relief showing a large armed warrior flanked by smaller attendants.
Benin brass plaque depicting a warrior and attendants, 16th–17th century.

Egharevba identifies communities in Iyekorhiomwo, east of the Orhionmwon River, among the recurring targets of Ozolua's campaigns. The opponents he names include Elekidi of Ogbelaka, Okhonmiovo of Iguisi village, Egbaen of Iwu, Ise of Utekon, Ogiemabo of Oka village, Atabatibo of Ogbe village, Idemu of Evbiakagba village, Aighalama of Ishan, Ohekeghede of Idumwoza village, Ese-Uhe of Amagba village, Ovbierhe, Okeze, Ogigbehu, Olokhumwu, Ovbivbi and Egbomarhuan of Okhumwu village. Egharevba presents the fighting against these opponents as a series of extended punitive operations that could continue for months before resistance ended.[5][39] Ryder identifies Ishan as the principal zone of Ozolua's territorial expansion.[4] Bradbury states that much of Ishan remained linked to Benin until the British conquest, although individual chiefdoms could defect and later be reconquered. He also records the tradition that Ozolua died during warfare at Uzia, while noting that it cannot be determined whether that campaign represented an initial conquest or the suppression of rebellion.[40] Sargent connects the expansion closely with control over hinterland commerce and long-distance trading routes.[39]

Ejide, Siluko and Owo

[edit]

Egharevba records a campaign against Origbo, a chief based at Ejide in the Siluko district. After defeating Origbo, Ozolua seized valuables that included musical instruments later associated with the Emaba royal dance.[5] Roese and Bondarenko likewise place the confrontation with Origbo along Ozolua's westward route towards Ijebu-Ode.[32] According to Egharevba, the inhabitants of Owo submitted when Ozolua approached rather than engage his forces in battle. He connects Ozolua's decision not to destroy the town with wordplay involving Owo or Ogho as a term associated with respect.[5] Roese and Bondarenko describe Owo as a commercial centre that attempted to escape Benin authority before being brought under Ozolua's control again.[32]

Smith treats the relationship between Benin and Owo with greater caution, noting that Owo traditions emphasised political independence while Egharevba's Benin history records attacks during the reigns of both Ewuare and Ozolua.[41] From the differing traditions, Smith suggests that Owo probably retained considerable autonomy in its capital and surrounding district while intermittently paying tribute to Benin and perhaps conceding southern territories important to routes leading to the coast.[42] Historian Stephen Adebanji Akintoye notes that both Benin and Owo traditions agree that Ozolua conquered or subjected Owo, although they differ over the consequences. The Benin account states that a Benin prince was installed as ruler, whereas Owo tradition remembers the conquest without acknowledging the installation of such a prince.[43]

Ijebu-Ode

[edit]

Egharevba states that Ozolua's forces conquered Ijebu-Ode and that the Oba exercised rule over Ijebuland for a number of years.[5] Kaplan and Ebohon also state that Ozolua conquered Ijebu-Ode and its surrounding territory.[21] [6] Ryder questions a literal interpretation of the conquest tradition, arguing that the distance involved and the known strength of Ijebu-Ode make a straightforward permanent occupation doubtful. He instead suggests that the story may preserve the memory of a Benin victory in a frontier conflict between two expanding political spheres.[4]

Roese and Bondarenko likewise regard the capture of Ijebu-Ode as uncertain. They nevertheless note later traditions of Benin–Ijebu political relationships and point to the early-sixteenth-century appearance of Ijebu-Ode as "Gebuu" in Portuguese geographical accounts.[32] They also refer to later evidence of political association, including author G. A. Robertson's 1819 description of "Jaboo" as a Benin viceroyalty, although that evidence dates from a much later period than Ozolua's reign.[32]

Smith notes that Ijebu traditions do not record Egharevba's claim that Ozolua conquered and governed the kingdom for several years. He nevertheless points out that Olfert Dapper's account of 1686 described the ruler of "Jaboe", identified with Ijebu, as a vassal of the Oba of the Kingdom of Benin.[44] Smith considers it plausible that Benin later exercised authority over at least parts of southern Ijebu territory, given Benin's westward coastal influence and communication with Lagos. He suggests that the Mahin creeks and lagoon routes may have been more important to this connection than a direct overland passage through the interior of Ijebu.[45] Sargent regards Ijebu-Ode as among Ozolua's strategically significant military successes because of its position relative to interior markets and east–west commercial routes.[39]

[edit]

Ebohon includes Ondo among the places conquered by Ozolua.[6] Smith records a Benin tradition in which migrants from Benin founded the Ondo kingship during Ozolua's reign, while contrasting this with separate traditions deriving the dynasty from Oyo or Ife.[42]

The traditions of Idoani provide a more detailed connection with Ozolua. Akintoye states that both Benin and Idoani traditions identify the first Alani ('ruler') of Idoani as Ozolua's son. Under the Benin version, Ozolua deliberately sent the prince with a substantial following to assume rule at Idoani, rather than the prince departing after a dispute over succession. Both versions also attribute Benin's later avoidance of military action against Idoani to this dynastic relationship.[46] Akintoye cautions that not every dynasty claiming Benin origin necessarily resulted from a direct royal installation, since individuals from Benin could also have taken advantage of Benin military expansion to establish themselves independently.[47] Roese and Bondarenko identify Alani, also called Ani or Eware in some traditions, as a son of Ozolua who became Idoani's first ruler. They note the continued use of Alani as the royal title and identify additional Benin-derived titles in the local political system.[32]

Egharevba identifies Uguan as a son of Ozolua and links his descendants with Ora village.[48] Bradbury records a strong Ivbiosakon tradition that Ora's founder descended from Ozolua, although he observes that some Ora traditions correspond more easily with an earlier chronology.[49] In the fuller genealogy recorded by Bradbury, Ora-Ekpen or Eranrin-Ekpen was the son of Uguan, who was himself remembered as a banished son of Ozolua.[50] Bradbury states that tradition derives the seven villages of Ora from twelve remembered sons of Ora-Ekpen.[50]

Bradbury also records several incompatible accounts concerning Uza of Ozala. One makes Uza a son of Ozolua who was banished for having sexual relations with one of his father's wives, another describes him as Ozolua's servant, while Ora traditions instead associate him with Uguan or one of Uguan's followers.[50] A tradition from Aviele town similarly places the founder's migration from Benin in Ozolua's reign, approximately around 1485. The founder is said first to have settled north of the Orle River before later movements brought the community towards the area of Agbede.[51]

Provincial government and dynastic appointments

[edit]

Historians record that Oba Ozolua appointed his sons as chiefs or established dynasties over numerous conquered towns and villages. Egharevba, Kaplan, and Ebohon trace the royal appointments or lineages of several regional rulers back to Ozolua's sons, including the Alani of Idoani, the Olokpe of Okpe, the Olowo (or Owa) of Owo, the Oguan (or Uguan) of Ora, the Eze of Aboh, and the Awujale of Ijebu-Ode.[52][21][6] Ryder states that conquered communities could be placed under members of the royal family and that Ozolua was especially remembered for settling numerous sons in such positions.[53] Ryder describes the resulting structure as one in which some subordinate chiefdoms preserved substantial autonomy over their internal affairs while continuing to maintain ritual and dynastic ties with Benin.[54] Sargent interprets the appointment of royal sons as governors as an extension of earlier methods of regional administration, but argues that these governors could also become centres of separatist power whenever the authority of the capital weakened.[34]

Relations with Portugal

[edit]

Background and first direct contact

[edit]
Brass relief with a large central royal figure, two kneeling attendants and two smaller European figures.
Sixteenth-century Benin brass plaque depicting an Oba, two kneeling attendants and two Portuguese figures.

Portuguese mariners had reached the Bight of Benin before the establishment of direct relations with the Benin court.[55] Ryder states that Portuguese vessels explored the section of the West African coast corresponding to modern Nigeria between 1469 and 1475 and notes António Galvão's attribution of a 1472 voyage through the Bight of Benin to Ruy de Sequeira.[56] Portuguese merchants later entered the river systems of the Bight while seeking enslaved people for exchange on the Gold Coast.[57] Ryder identifies the Benin and Forçados rivers as among the most likely locations of these earliest Portuguese slave-trading voyages in the region.[58]

The coastal peoples first encountered by Portuguese merchants were primarily Ijo and other delta communities rather than the Edo population centred in Benin.[59] Ryder stresses that the Kingdom of Benin was an inland state whose political centre lay beyond the swamp forest and whose inhabitants were not principally riverine canoe users. Portuguese merchants could consequently operate in the coastal waterways before establishing direct contact with Benin's monarchy.[60] The decision to send a representative inland emerged during the reign of João II of Portugal.[61] Ryder dates João Afonso d'Aveiro's mission to Benin to 1486 and links it with Portuguese commercial, political, missionary and exploratory interests. He proposes that knowledge of Benin may have reached Portuguese officials through coastal intermediaries, groups associated with dynastic offshoots of Benin or captives originating in the interior, while treating these possibilities as hypotheses rather than documented routes of information.[62]

No surviving narrative was written by d'Aveiro himself. Ryder considers it likely that he travelled by river to Ughoton, Benin's port, before continuing overland to the capital.[63] Benin tradition identifies Ozolua as the Oba who received these Portuguese visitors.[63][64] Blackmun likewise identifies Ozolua as the ruler who welcomed the earliest European merchants and missionaries, basing the attribution on correlations between documentary and oral evidence.[65] Bradbury describes the tradition placing the first European arrival during Ozolua's reign as particularly well established, while noting that one account collected in 1897 instead assigned the event to Esigie, Ozolua's son and successor.[64] Curnow adopts a different chronology and states that Portuguese visitors had already arrived during the reign of Ozolua's elder brother.[30]

Diplomacy and commerce

[edit]
Tall carved ivory vessel with standing human figures arranged around its sides.
Benin–Portuguese ivory saltcellar decorated with Portuguese figures, c. 1525 – c. 1600.

Ryder states that Ozolua's court showed considerable interest in the visitors and agreed that the chief of Ughoton should accompany them back to Portugal. Portuguese authorities commonly encouraged such journeys to demonstrate Portuguese resources and royal prestige to African dignitaries. The Ughoton chief's selection reflected both his association with the royal house and the importance of his settlement as Benin's port.[63] Ryder states that the Oba authorised commerce in enslaved people and other products sought by Portuguese merchants.[66] Benin pepper, which Ryder identifies as Piper guineense, became commercially attractive after d'Aveiro brought samples for testing in European markets. Portuguese traders considered the so-called tailed pepper a potential alternative to other West African varieties.[67]

Kaplan describes the encounter of 1486 more specifically as the conclusion of a formal commercial agreement between d'Aveiro and Ozolua.[21] Curnow states that commerce linked to Ozolua's court involved pepper, ivory, leopard and cheetah skins, wax, gum, textiles and prisoners of war exchanged for silks, velvets, red woolens, metals, coral and other beads and mirrors.[30] Egharevba attributes the introduction of guns and coconuts into Benin to d'Aveiro's visit of 1485–1486.[68] Blackmun states that Benin memory of Ozolua's relationship with Europeans placed particular emphasis on access to iron weapons and armor.[65] Hastings interprets Ozolua's later diplomatic engagement with Portugal as motivated substantially by his attempt to acquire firearms and cannon.[23]

Trading post at Ughoton

[edit]

After the chief of Ughoton returned from Portugal, Portuguese officials headed by d'Aveiro accompanied him with instructions to establish a royal trading post. The establishment was intended to direct Benin commerce, particularly the pepper trade, through the Portuguese crown's commercial system. D'Aveiro later died at Ughoton.[69] Ryder describes the subsequent history of the post as irregular and poorly documented.[70] Duarte Lopes died at Ughoton after arriving in 1504, while Bastiam Fernandez was probably among the final royal factors before the establishment closed in 1506–1507. Ryder cautions that the post probably did not operate continuously from its foundation until its closure. The visits of Duarte Pacheco Pereira to Benin in the 1490s contain no definite reference to a permanent Portuguese factor either at Ughoton or at the Benin capital.[71]

Ryder attributes the difficulties of the Ughoton post to limited commercial returns, high mortality among Europeans stationed there and the Oba's limited response to Portuguese attempts at Christian conversion. He also stresses that relations with Portugal formed only one component of Benin's political and economic life and did not immediately transform Benin society.[71]

Slave trade and warfare

[edit]

The Portuguese crown did not possess an exclusive monopoly over all trade in the "slave rivers". Ryder notes that some coastal territories used by Portuguese merchants before they established direct relations with Benin lay outside Benin's political jurisdiction, while Portuguese settlers, crown agents and private concession-holders all participated in regional commerce.[72] Ryder states that Ijo, Itsekiri and Edo suppliers provided enslaved people through established markets, judicial enslavement, social exclusion and the sale of prisoners taken in war. He considers it likely that Ozolua's numerous campaigns increased the number of captives available for sale, but explicitly rejects the conclusion that European demand for enslaved people caused Ozolua to undertake those conquests.[73]

Ryder identifies São Jorge da Mina, São Tomé, Príncipe and Lisbon among the destinations to which enslaved people acquired from the region were sent.[74] He estimates that the Portuguese crown acquired relatively limited numbers of enslaved people annually from the broader region while the Ughoton establishment operated and emphasises that these captives did not all originate in Benin itself. Portuguese documents cited by Ryder also record instances in which the Oba presented enslaved people as gifts to Portuguese officials.[75] Hastings interprets the diplomatic negotiations of 1514 differently, characterising Portuguese interest as strongly focused on slave commerce while describing Benin as unwilling to supply the trade under the conditions sought by Portugal.[23]

Religion and Christian missions

[edit]

Bradbury states that Benin traditions contain relatively little material directly connecting Ozolua himself with the Portuguese apart from the strong memory that their first visit occurred during his reign. One tradition collected by Bradbury states that Ozolua became suspicious that the Europeans were plotting with his son Esigie and that Esigie advised them to leave and return after he became Oba.[64] Roese and Bondarenko preserve a comparable account in which Esigie, still crown prince, formed close relationships with Portuguese visitors. Ozolua feared that his son and the Europeans could be conspiring against him, whereas Esigie reportedly encouraged his Portuguese associates to return once he was king.[76]

Kaplan states that Ozolua sent his first son, Esigie, to Portugal for a period while the prince held the title Edaiken. According to Kaplan, Esigie learned to read and write Portuguese there, and a tradition further states that he came back with a Portuguese wife.[21] Nzegwu instead states that Ozolua sent Esigie to a Portuguese mission school after the prince's baptism.[29] Curnow gives another reconstruction in which Ozolua, hoping to secure Portuguese firearms, offered Esigie as a prospective convert to Christianity. In that account, Esigie learned to speak, read and write Portuguese, probably studied some Latin and was baptised, but Portugal continued to deny Ozolua the weapons he wanted because Esigie was not yet the reigning monarch.[30]

Sargent states that Benin tradition remembers Ozolua as permitting or encouraging Christian missionary activity in the capital without becoming closely associated with the missionaries himself. Sargent identifies Esigie as the royal figure most strongly connected with them, stating that he learned written and spoken Portuguese and displayed an apparent commitment to Christianity that increased Ozolua's suspicions.[28] Sargent interprets the emerging political divisions by associating Esigie with Atlantic trade and Christianity, Ozolua with Ifa and Aruanran at Udo with the Aro oracle.[39] Hastings states that Ozolua sent a mission to Lisbon in 1514 expressing interest in conversion to Christianity while also requesting firearms, including cannon. The Portuguese crown promised to send clergy but withheld weapons until the Oba accepted Christianity, while encouraging him to open Benin's markets more freely to commerce.[23]

Hastings states that missionaries arrived in Benin in 1515 but that Ozolua, occupied with military affairs, did not convert. The missionaries subsequently withdrew after concluding that royal conversion was unlikely.[23] Hastings also records an Edo Christian named Gregorio Lourenço, who had lived on São Tomé, learned Portuguese and converted there before returning to Benin, where he acted as an interpreter in 1515.[77] Lourenço continued to be involved with Christianity after Ozolua's reign and remained associated with missionaries and Christian practice during the 1520s and 1530s.[78]

Royal household and court

[edit]

Idia and other wives

[edit]
Ivory face mask with rows of beads below the chin and small figures along the crown.
Sixteenth-century ivory pendant mask identified with Idia, one of Ozolua's wives and the mother of Osawe.

Nzegwu states that Idia entered Ozolua's royal household after attracting the ruler's attention while participating in a dance in the Benin capital. Once arrangements for the marriage began, Idia's relatives subjected her to medicinal preparation intended to strengthen her for palace life.[79] Nzegwu describes Idia as strong-willed and as already possessing ritual or medicinal knowledge before and during her marriage to Ozolua.[80]

Curnow identifies another wife, Ohomwin, as Arhuaran's mother and states that she was favoured by Ozolua. Curnow identifies Idia as Esigie's mother and places competition between the two women and their sons within the background to the later succession crisis.[30] Roese and Bondarenko identify Egbe as the wife who advised Ozolua to withdraw from Benin to Ora before his accession.[14] Egharevba identifies Eyowo as a later wife whom Ozolua married after the death of her first husband, the Elekidi of Ogbelaka, before later ordering Eyowo's execution.[5]

Enahen and Okpota

[edit]

Egharevba records a palace tradition concerning Enahen, whom he describes as a powerful sorceress within Ozolua's harem. According to the account, Enahen repeatedly showed hostility towards Ozolua and was eventually killed during an incident in which the Oba lost one of his fingers.[52]

Another tradition preserved by Egharevba concerns Okpota, a ritual practitioner from Ishan who arrived in Benin during Ozolua's reign. Okpota approached the palace and explained why he had come, after which the Oba provided him with accommodation near the royal compound. Roughly two weeks later, Okpota offered to prepare a charm for Ozolua and requested several costly ingredients. Ozolua first instructed him to make the charm for himself; when Okpota explained that he lacked the wealth to obtain the necessary materials, the Oba supplied them.[52]

After completing the charm, Okpota placed it in a pot at the entrance to his own residence. The tradition states that gifts then began to arrive from across the Benin capital, including repeated presents from Ozolua. Egharevba further records that one of Ozolua's daughters chose Okpota as her husband instead of the man selected by her father. Ozolua subsequently provided another set of ingredients so that Okpota could prepare a similar charm for the entrance to the Oba's chamber.[52] The place became associated with Ugha-Ozolua ('Ozolua's court') and with the continued presentation of gifts to the Oba.[52] Okpota became wealthy and influential at court, while the entrance to his former residence came to be known as Urho-Okpota ('Okpota's gate').[52] Egharevba locates the site near the former Benin Divisional Secretariat and records that later Obas including Akengbedo, Akenzua I and Osemwede stayed there before their coronations.[52]

Military retainers

[edit]

Egharevba identifies Enowe as a warrior whom Ozolua brought from Ughoha in Ishan to serve in his campaigns. After Ozolua died, Enowe continued his military service under Esigie and was credited with several victories. Egharevba records that a bangle and girdle associated with Enowe were later excavated near his shrine at Idumwu-Ughoha and placed in the Benin Museum.[81] Elaisolobi (or Laisolobi) was another military companion trusted by Ozolua.[65][5][38]

Children and succession planning

[edit]

Ogidogbo, Osawe and Aruanran

[edit]

Egharevba names Ozolua's first three sons as Ogidogbo, Osawe and Aruanran. One tradition relates that the three tested their strength by trying to pole-jump across the pond Agbodo. Ogidogbo fell during the contest, broke his legs and was permanently disabled, making him ineligible for kingship under prevailing expectations that the ruler should be physically unimpaired. He was instead appointed Ogie-Idogbo, ruler of Idogbo.[81][30]

According to Egharevba, Osawe and Aruanran were born on the same day. Although Aruanran physically arrived first, news of Osawe's birth reached the palace first, leading custom to recognise Osawe as the senior prince. Once Ogidogbo could no longer succeed, Osawe became the acknowledged heir, intensifying hostility between him and Aruanran.[81] Curnow gives a fuller version of this birth-order narrative, identifying Ohomwin as Arhuaran's mother and Idia as Osawe's mother. In her account, Ohomwin delivered Arhuaran first but delayed notifying the palace because Ogidogbo remained firmly established as heir. Idia reported Osawe's birth more quickly, causing palace records and custom to recognise Osawe as senior to Arhuaran.[30]

Egharevba records traditions in which Aruanran made repeated attempts to assassinate Osawe. He also states that Aruanran visited an elderly woman at Uroho to learn black magic for use against his brother.[81] Nzegwu likewise records both Aruanran's attempts against Osawe and the tradition that he sought occult instruction from a woman at Uroho.[29] Curnow states that Arhuaran's physical power and reputation as a fighter made him Ozolua's favoured son. She contrasts this with Osawe's intellectual interests and lesser involvement in athletic activity, which she describes as contributing to distance between him and his father.[30] Nzegwu similarly suggests that Osawe's schooling may have reduced his military experience because it kept him away from some of Ozolua's campaigns.[29] Blackmun states that Ozolua favoured Aruaran and granted him important honours, including sacred beaded regalia connected with kingship. She argues that these honours encouraged Aruaran to expect that he would eventually become king.[24]

Aruanran at Udo

[edit]

Curnow records an oral tradition in which Ozolua appointed Aruanran to administer Udo on Benin's behalf.[82] After Arhuaran defeated one of Ozolua's enemies during the Oba's absence, Ozolua decided to establish him at Udo with an adviser, sons of chiefs, guild craftsmen and royal regalia. Curnow states that Arhuaran received a ritually prepared ceremonial sword, or eben, together with an instruction not to let its point touch the ground until he arrived at Udo. Under the tradition, whichever place first received the sword's point would become the "New Benin", which would allow Udo eventually to supersede the Benin capital.[83]

After discovering the plan, Osawe accompanied Arhuaran's procession through the capital. Curnow records that Osawe repeatedly encouraged his half-brother to lower the sword towards successive shrines until Arhuaran finally allowed the blade to touch the ground before leaving Benin.[83] Tradition interprets the incident as fixing the "New Benin" within the existing capital instead of transferring that ritual status to Udo.[83] Sargent regards Aruanran's installation at Udo as one of the developments that later contributed to civil war between Aruanran and Osawe.[84]

Final campaign, death and succession

[edit]

Uromi campaign

[edit]

In Egharevba's chronology, around 1503 Agba, the Ogie or Onojie of Uromi, rejected Ozolua's authority and attempted to organise resistance across Ishan. Egharevba states that Agba called upon other Ishan communities to join him against Benin. After repeated warnings produced no submission, Ozolua prepared a campaign against Uromi. Agba initially sought aid from the Attah of Igala but returned home without obtaining the assistance he had requested.[81] Roese and Bondarenko likewise state that Agba appealed to Igala and that the Attah declined to intervene.[38] Sargent identifies the Igala ruler in this tradition as Egarah Eri and states that he rejected Agba's appeal partly because he feared Ozolua might redirect Benin forces towards the Okpoto capital.[85]

Roese and Bondarenko record another version, associated with the Ishan historian Christopher Okojie, in which the rebellion arose from resentment of Ozolua's treatment of the inhabitants of Uromi. Under that account, Uromi withheld its annual tribute in 1502, prompting Ozolua to prepare for war.[38] Ozolua marched through Uzea, or Uzia, and established a military base there.[81][38] Egharevba states that Uzea was subdued, its ruler executed and the settlement then used as Ozolua's base against Uromi. After prolonged warfare, Benin troops surrounded Uromi and forced Agba to surrender after approximately three months.[81]

Egharevba states that Agba died by suicide while Uromi was suffering from starvation and depopulation and that his body could not be recovered for removal to Benin. Instead, the head of Uzea's ruler was reproduced in brass as a trophy, which Egharevba records as later being displayed in the Benin Museum.[81] Sargent gives a different continuation of the narrative, stating that Agba's unsuccessful appeal for outside support revealed to Ozolua more about the strength of Igala. According to Sargent, Ozolua then sent his son Aji-Attah towards the Okpoto capital with settlers and a section of the army while retaining most of his forces for the campaign against Uromi. Sargent states that Ozolua eventually defeated Agba after extended fighting and that Uromi's forces fled before the Benin army.[85]

Death traditions

[edit]

Accounts agree that Ozolua died during or immediately after the Uromi campaign, but they differ substantially in explaining his death. Egharevba states that Ozolua died at Uzea while returning from the campaign after being poisoned by his own soldiers, who resented what the tradition describes as his selfishness and lack of gratitude.[81] Sargent likewise records a tradition in which Ozolua's own troops poisoned him at the conclusion of the conflict.[85] Ryder describes the episode more generally as a revolt by soldiers exhausted by Ozolua's continued pursuit of war. Under Ryder's account, the troops eventually killed their ruler to bring the Uromi campaign to an end.[4]

Roese and Bondarenko preserve several competing explanations. One states that Ozolua was killed by his own exhausted soldiers, while others describe a conspiracy through which one of his servants or generals betrayed him to people from Uzea. The latter tradition commonly names Elaisolo or Laisoiobi, who supposedly turned against Ozolua after the Oba first gave him a wife and later took her back. In one version, conspirators tunnelled towards Ozolua's bathing place, allowing Uzea fighters to attack him there. Ozolua was said to have resisted his attackers while calling for his Iyase, who arrived only after the ruler had been killed.[38]

Blackmun records a related account of betrayal in which Ozolua's repeated campaigning exhausted the army and weakened its willingness to continue fighting.[65] She states that Elaisolobi, remembered as one of Ozolua's trusted military companions, was persuaded to betray him to his enemies, leading to the Oba's death.[65] Sargent interprets the soldiers' actions as evidence of pressures created by Ozolua's military system. He argues that repeated mobilisation, tribute obligations and other levies probably imposed heavy demands on sections of the population even while conquest enlarged the number of tributary communities.[36] Ozolua's body was returned to the Benin capital for burial.[81] Curnow records a succession narrative in which possession of his corpse became politically important because burial of the dead Oba and establishment of his ancestral altar were prerequisites for Osawe's claim to succeed him.[83]

Burial and succession

[edit]
Black-and-white view of a palace altar area with upright carved ivory tusks and ceremonial objects.
An ancestral shrine in the Oba's palace compound, photographed in 1891.

Curnow states that Ozolua died north of the kingdom's political centre and that his body therefore had to pass through Udo while being transported back to the Benin capital. According to the tradition she records, Arhuaran planned to intercept the corpse, conduct his father's burial himself and use the funeral to strengthen his own claim to the throne. Osawe's supporters instead sent a richly prepared decoy funeral procession through Udo while Ozolua's actual body was carried inconspicuously beyond Arhuaran. Arhuaran seized the ceremonial coffin, only to discover that it contained a log, while the real body reached Osawe in Benin. Osawe then buried his father and was crowned under the name Esigie.[83]

Blackmun similarly states that Osawe claimed the throne after Ozolua died on campaign despite Aruaran's expectation that he would succeed. Civil war then developed between the two half-brothers.[24][83] Blackmun states that Osawe eventually defeated Aruaran with substantial assistance from his mother Idia, while Aruaran destroyed the royal beads he had received and died.[24] Nzegwu places particular emphasis on Idia's contribution to the subsequent struggle and associates Esigie's comparatively limited military experience with the time he had spent receiving Portuguese schooling rather than campaigning with Ozolua.[29] Curnow records traditions in which Idia employed ritual knowledge and deception near Unuame to induce sections of Arhuaran's forces to abandon him and join Osawe.[83] Sargent states that Esigie carried out only limited reprisals for his father's assassination. He proposes either that Osawe was chiefly concerned with consolidating his own authority or that Ozolua's policies had already imposed an unsustainable burden on the resources of the state.[22]

Legacy

[edit]

Egharevba connects Ozolua's reign with several migrations from Benin. He identifies the people of Ora as descendants of Uguan, a son of Ozolua whom the Oba left behind when returning from exile. Egharevba also states that Sobe or Uhgbe, Ijagba and Uhie were founded after Ozolua's death by soldiers who had participated in the Uzea campaign.[68] He similarly attributes the foundation of Ifon to Ozolua's soldiers together with eight migrants from Yorubaland.[68]

Egharevba further associates Benin princes with the establishment of rulers in Ishan and treats many Ishan Enigie (or Enije) as descendants or appointees of Benin's royal house.[68] Bradbury's study of Ivbiosakon origin traditions likewise records widespread claims of migration from Benin and identifies Ozolua's reign as a chronological marker in traditions from Ora and Aviele.[86] Akintoye places the creation of several Benin-linked dynasties in northeastern Yorubaland within the broader period of Benin's military expansion.[47] He states that trade between Benin and northeastern Yoruba regions either preceded or accompanied political intervention and identifies Okeluse and Akure as major entrepôts on routes connecting Benin with Akoko, Iyagba, Nupe, Ife, Ijesha and other Yoruba areas.[43]

Notes and references

[edit]

Explanatory notes

[edit]
  1. ↑ The Iyase is the commander-in-chief of the Benin warriors, followed by the Ezomo and the Ologbosere and Imaran.[15]

Citations

[edit]
  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Egharevba 1968, p. 22.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Ebohon 2005, p. 109.
  3. 1 2 3 Sargent 1984, pp. 108–109.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Ryder 1969, p. 12.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Egharevba 1968, p. 23.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 Ebohon 2005, p. 90.
  7. ↑ Egharevba 1968, pp. 25–26.
  8. 1 2 3 Sargent 1984, p. 108.
  9. ↑ Ebohon 2005, pp. 90, 109.
  10. 1 2 Sargent 1984, p. 109.
  11. 1 2 Sargent 1984, p. 112.
  12. 1 2 Sargent 1984, pp. 112, 114.
  13. 1 2 3 Sargent 1984, p. 114.
  14. 1 2 Roese & Bondarenko 2003, p. 96.
  15. ↑ Egharevba 1968, p. 80.
  16. ↑ Roese & Bondarenko 2003, pp. 96–97.
  17. 1 2 3 4 Roese & Bondarenko 2003, p. 97.
  18. 1 2 Bradbury 1973, p. 23.
  19. 1 2 Smith 1988, p. 84.
  20. ↑ Egharevba 1968, pp. 22, 26.
  21. 1 2 3 4 5 Kaplan 2004, p. 185.
  22. 1 2 Sargent 1984, p. 122.
  23. 1 2 3 4 5 Hastings 1994, p. 77.
  24. 1 2 3 4 Blackmun 1994, p. 96.
  25. ↑ Bradbury 1973, p. 36.
  26. ↑ Bradbury 1973, pp. 36–37.
  27. 1 2 Sargent 1984, pp. 114–115.
  28. 1 2 Sargent 1984, p. 115.
  29. 1 2 3 4 5 Nzegwu 2005, p. 43.
  30. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Curnow 2024, p. 288.
  31. 1 2 Roese & Bondarenko 2003, pp. 98–99.
  32. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Roese & Bondarenko 2003, p. 98.
  33. ↑ Sargent 1984, pp. 119–120.
  34. 1 2 Sargent 1984, p. 119.
  35. ↑ Sargent 1984, p. 120.
  36. 1 2 Sargent 1984, p. 121.
  37. ↑ Blackmun 1994, pp. 96, 107.
  38. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Roese & Bondarenko 2003, p. 99.
  39. 1 2 3 4 Sargent 1984, p. 116.
  40. ↑ Bradbury 1957, p. 64.
  41. ↑ Smith 1988, p. 51.
  42. 1 2 Smith 1988, p. 52.
  43. 1 2 Akintoye 1969, p. 544.
  44. ↑ Smith 1988, p. 66.
  45. ↑ Smith 1988, pp. 66–67.
  46. ↑ Akintoye 1969, p. 541.
  47. 1 2 Akintoye 1969, pp. 543–544.
  48. ↑ Egharevba 1968, pp. 24, 26.
  49. ↑ Bradbury 1957, p. 85.
  50. 1 2 3 Bradbury 1957, p. 87.
  51. ↑ Bradbury 1957, p. 102.
  52. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Egharevba 1968, p. 24.
  53. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 12–13.
  54. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 13.
  55. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 24, 26–28.
  56. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 24.
  57. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 26.
  58. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 26–27.
  59. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 27–28.
  60. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 28.
  61. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 28–29.
  62. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 29.
  63. 1 2 3 Ryder 1969, p. 30.
  64. 1 2 3 Bradbury 1973, p. 35.
  65. 1 2 3 4 5 Blackmun 1994, p. 107.
  66. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 30–31.
  67. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 31.
  68. 1 2 3 4 Egharevba 1968, p. 26.
  69. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 32.
  70. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 32–33.
  71. 1 2 Ryder 1969, p. 33.
  72. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 34.
  73. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 35.
  74. ↑ Ryder 1969, pp. 35–36.
  75. ↑ Ryder 1969, p. 36.
  76. ↑ Roese & Bondarenko 2003, pp. 97–98.
  77. ↑ Hastings 1994, pp. 77–78.
  78. ↑ Hastings 1994, p. 78.
  79. ↑ Nzegwu 2005, p. 44.
  80. ↑ Nzegwu 2005, pp. 43–44.
  81. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Egharevba 1968, p. 25.
  82. ↑ Curnow 2024, pp. 288–289.
  83. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Curnow 2024, p. 289.
  84. ↑ Sargent 1984, pp. 115–116.
  85. 1 2 3 Sargent 1984, p. 118.
  86. ↑ Bradbury 1957, pp. 85, 102.

Works cited

[edit]