Draft talk:SuperCarlinBrothers

SCB Genre

The SCB Genre is Fan Theory. Film Theory implies that they talk about Cinematography, Quality of Production, and the like.Rwm geekteach (talk) 19:53, 16 October 2020 (UTC)

Notability

Spoke with some of the Wikipedia Reviewers tonight. Learned a few things:

1. YouTube is not considered a reliable source at all - doesn't matter who the author is.
2. MuggleNet and DCast are fan sites and hold no official standing with their said fandoms.
3. A Nomination for a Streamy is not enough to establish notability.

So, we need to find Videos that are linked on established sites, like we did with the WSLS 10 video. Don't link to the YouTube video, but the news site that links to the video. And also, we need to see if we can find official fandom recognitions of the Brothers - or award WINS and not just nominations. They need to be officially recognized by somebody important in the fandom communities. Rwm geekteach (talk) 06:11, 19 October 2020 (UTC)

List of possible proofs of notability:

I've (tubbdoose) collected some things I think are proof of notability

• They were on the front page of pottermore (sadly the image doesn't show...): https://web.archive.org/web/20180227214418/https://www.pottermore.com/
• The article on pottermore that they were featured in: https://www.pottermore.com/news/explore-the-british-librarys-harry-potter-a-history-of-magic-exhibition-with-google-arts-and-culture
• Featured by Google arts and Culture: https://artsandculture.google.com/project/harry-potter-a-history-of-magic
• Mentioned by polygon: https://www.polygon.com/2017/6/26/15874548/toy-story-andy-dad-theory
• Mentioned by Mashable: https://mashable.com/article/toy-story-andy-father-viral-story

TubbDoose (talk) 23:27, 28 August 2021 (UTC)

• Winning Roanoker's Best Local Influencer and Best Local Podcast are huge! However since we were specifically asked to wait 5 years, I think we should wait to have at least one more large notable recognition before officially resubmitting.

Geekteach (talk) 23:58, 7 May 2022 (UTC)

Transclusion of source assessment table

Source assessment table

Source	Independent?	Reliable?	Significant coverage?	Count source toward GNG?
Jones, Meghan (June 21, 2019). "Is This What Really Happened to Andy's Dad in "Toy Story"?". Yahoo! Life.				? Unknown
Ellis, Phillip (November 15, 2020). "This 'Star Wars' Theory Suggests the Mandalorian Is About to Get a Lightsaber". Yahoo! Life.				? Unknown
"6 Informative YouTube Channels To Check Out". The Nerd Daily. November 18, 2018.		Probably wouldn't count		✘ No
Laing, Marica (December 4, 2019). "Girl Makes Startling "Harry Potter" Discovery at Wimbledon Library". MuggleNet. Retrieved October 18, 2020.		Fan site		✘ No
Flowers, Brittany (September 20, 2017). "The Super Carlin Brothers visit Daytime!". WSLS 10. Retrieved October 16, 2020.		Probably wouldn't count		✘ No
"Harry Potter: Dumbledore's Horcrux Theory (& Why Rowling Hates It)". ScreenRant. 2019-12-31. Retrieved 2021-08-26.		WP:SCREENRANT		? Unknown
"Toy Story: Woody Originally Belonged To Andy's Dad - Theory Explained". ScreenRant. 2021-08-09. Retrieved 2021-08-26.		WP:SCREENRANT		? Unknown
Vitto, Laura (2017-06-25). "Pixar writer says that viral 'Toy Story' narrative is 'fake news'". Mashable. Retrieved 2021-08-26.		WP:MASHABLE		? Unknown
Alexander, Julia (2017-06-26). "New theory over origin of Andy's dad in Toy Story sparks debate after alleged report". Polygon. Retrieved 2021-08-26.		WP:POLYGON (pre-May 2025)		? Unknown
Brooks, Nicholas (2022-03-03). "Could Fantastic Beasts' Jacob Kowalski Actually Be a Wizard?". CBR. Retrieved 2022-08-18.		WP:CBR		✘ No
"NerdCon: Nerdfighteria Schedule". nerdconnerdfighteria2017.sched.com. Retrieved 2022-08-17.				? Unknown
"RTX Austin 2022 :: Leap Conventions". register.growtix.com. Retrieved 2024-03-08.				? Unknown
Ganley, Michelle (2022-06-03). "Hey, brother! How these siblings from Roanoke, Virginia became the oh-so popular 'Super Carlin Brothers'". WSLS. Retrieved 2022-08-17.		Probably wouldn't count		✘ No
"The DCast Rewind | Super Carlin Brothers (our first ever interview)". The DCast:PodBean. August 15, 2015. Retrieved October 16, 2020.	Interview	Fan site		✘ No
"Ben Carlin '12". Radford University. Archived from the original on 2020-10-19. Retrieved 2023-03-18.				✘ No
"Harry Potter: A History of Magic". Google Arts & Culture. Retrieved 2022-08-17.				? Unknown
"‎Popcorn Culture on Apple Podcasts". Apple Podcasts. Retrieved 2022-08-17.	Subject's podcast			✘ No
""GO Fest" Bringing Blues Music / Old Favorites and New Features for 2022". The Roanoke Star. 9 August 2022. Retrieved 17 August 2022.				✘ No
"Schedule - Roanoke GO Fest". Roanoke GO Fest. Retrieved 2024-03-13.			Schedule for an event	✘ No
"Think Like a Community Manager". Patreon. Retrieved 17 August 2022.				✘ No
O'Connor, Brendan. "A Very Normal Podcast Tour with Annual Pass + Super Carlin Brothers". Bungalower. Retrieved 2022-08-18.				✘ No
Sheehan, Gavin (2022-06-18). "RTX Austin 2022 Officially Returns As A Convention This July". Bleeding Cool News And Rumors. Retrieved 2022-08-18.				? Unknown
"The Pixar Theory - Every Pixar Movie is Connected". July 11, 2013.				? Unknown
Holliday, Christopher (2018-06-01), "Pixar, Performance and Puppets", The Computer-Animated Film, Edinburgh University Press, pp. 127–143, doi:10.3366/edinburgh/9781474427883.003.0007, ISBN 978-1-4744-2788-3, retrieved 2022-08-17				? Unknown
"Winners Announced for the 8th Annual Streamy Awards®". October 23, 2018. Retrieved October 16, 2020.			A nomination for a Streamy is not enough.	✘ No
"The 36th Annual Best of Roanoke Awards". Roanoker Magazine. May 2022. Retrieved May 5, 2022.			Describes the results of an awards ceremony	✘ No
Long, Liz (2023-05-16). "Best of Roanoke 2023". TheRoanoker.com. Retrieved 2024-03-13.			Describes the results of an awards ceremony	✘ No
Long, Liz (2023-01-03). "40 Under 40: Jonathan Carlin". TheRoanoker.com. Retrieved 2023-01-04.			~ 300 words at the top	? Unknown
"Bill Tracking - 2024 Session > Legislation". Retrieved 2024-03-13.			Purely concerns state legislation and has nothing to do with any content creator	✘ No
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using {{source assess table}}.

I haven't visited any of the sources myself, so my guesses regarding significant coverage may be wrong. – MrPersonHumanGuy (talk) 19:02, 12 November 2025 (UTC)

 Courtesy link: Wikipedia:Source assessment/SuperCarlinBrothers – MrPersonHumanGuy (talk) 19:30, 12 November 2025 (UTC)