Draft talk:GEMSEO

Source assessment table

Source assessment table prepared by User:Elbart32

Source	Independent?	Reliable?	Significant coverage?	Count source toward GNG?
Golombek, H.; Bustamante, J.; Maierl, R.; Staack, I. (2026). "An automated surrogate model generation framework for rapid aeroelastic structural sizing optimizations in conceptual aircraft design". CEAS Aeronautical Journal. doi:10.1007/s13272-026-00996-6	Authors are at DLR and TU Braunschweig, neither connected to the project. One co-author works for Airbus Defence and Space, an industrial partner of the IRT project in which GEMSEO originated; none of the authors contributed to the software.	Peer-reviewed journal article.	Describes GEMSEO's optimization algorithms, sampling plans and surrogate generation throughout the methodology.	✔ Yes
Di Giuseppe, R.; Delbecq, S.; Budinger, V.; Pauvert, V. (2023). "An exploratory study of open-source frameworks for MDAO". AeroBest 2023 / II ECCOMAS Thematic Conference on MDO of Aerospace Systems, Lisbon.	ISAE-SUPAERO is an academic member of IRT Saint Exupéry, but none of the authors is connected to the GEMSEO project.	Peer-reviewed conference paper.	Comparative study of GEMSEO, OpenMDAO and CoSApp, with comparison tables.	✔ Yes
Putzu, R. (April 2025). Multidisciplinary Optimization of Next-Generation Aero-Engine Fans (PhD thesis). Università degli Studi di Cagliari.	No connection to the developers; funded by the European Commission and the Italian PON programme.	Doctoral thesis, defended April 2025.	Section 2.4, "Solving the Optimization Problem with GEMSEO", describes the software, its dependencies and its core abstractions.	✔ Yes
Granata, D.; Mancini, S.; Mateo-Gabin, A.; Zanotti, A. (2025). "Enhancing a Distributed Electric Propulsion Configuration Aircraft Design with a Multidisciplinary Analysis and Optimization Approach". European Rotorcraft Forum, paper ERF2025-019.	Led by Politecnico di Milano. Two co-authors work for Airbus Defence and Space, as noted for the first source.	Peer-reviewed conference paper.	Describes GEMSEO, its supported languages, its MDO formulations and its DOE and surrogate capabilities.	✔ Yes
Muradas Odriozola, D. (24 November 2025). Développement d'un cadre de conception optimale multidisciplinaire de la voilure et ses gouvernes avec prise en compte d'une loi d'allègement de charges (PhD thesis). ISAE-SUPAERO, Université de Toulouse.	Prepared at ISAE-SUPAERO under a CIFRE agreement with Airbus, both connected to IRT Saint Exupéry. Cited for technical content only, not offered for notability.	Doctoral thesis.	Section 3.1.2 is devoted to GEMSEO, with a comparative discussion of MDO frameworks.	✘ No
Cary, A. W.; et al. (2021). "CFD Vision 2030 Road Map: Progress and Perspectives". AIAA Aviation 2021 Forum. doi:10.2514/6.2021-2726	Prepared for NASA by authors unconnected to the project.	Peer-reviewed conference paper.	One-sentence mention. Offered as context, not for notability.	✘ No
Gallard et al. (2018); De Lozzo et al. (2025); Espoeys et al. (2026)	Written by the developers at IRT Saint Exupéry.	Peer-reviewed conference and journal papers.	Used only for uncontroversial technical and historical facts.	✘ No
gemseo.org and its documentation	Published by the project.	~ Primary source.	Used only for licence and release information.	✘ No
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using {{source assess table}}.

I have declared my conflict of interest above: I am employed by IRT Saint Exupéry, which develops GEMSEO. Since the last review I have removed the sources that were neither reliable nor independent, rewritten the technical description so that it rests on independent publications rather than on the project's own documentation, and added four independent sources that discuss GEMSEO itself, including a 2026 peer-reviewed journal article. Where an author has any institutional link to the project, I have said so in the table above rather than leave it to be discovered. Elbart32 (talk) 05:38, 18 September 2026 (UTC)