// Workers AI · dad joke modeWhat did Commission v Council say to the judge? "We're appealing to a higher council.

Commission v Council
Court	European Court of Justice
Citations	(1971) Case 22/70, [1971] ECR 263
Keywords
Legislation, legality

Commission v Council (1971) Case 22/70 is an EU law case, concerning the legality of legislative acts in the European Union.

Facts

Relating to the European Road Transport Agreement, a Council ‘resolution’ settled the negotiating procedure for an upcoming conference. The Commission challenged the resolution as being against EU law, and the only way to do this was to ask for annulment of the ‘resolution’. Could it be a subject of such proceedings? TEEC article 190 (now TFEU article 288) at the time stated that regulations, directive and decisions were only valid if they stated the reasons on which they were based.

Judgment

The Court of Justice held the list in (what is now) TFEU article 288 is not exhaustive, and Acts can be binding without falling into those categories. The resolution was a valid act outside the list.

See also

• European Union law

Further reading

• Butler, Graham; Wessel, Ramses A (2022). EU External Relations Law: The Cases in Context. Oxford: Hart Publishing/Bloomsbury. ISBN 9781509939695.